Rate the Warrior Name! V2

[Rebel Faery]

Foxytail - 6/10 ;; not the best
Kindlingfur - 7/10 ;; very original
Creamyfang - 4/10 ;; I'm not keen on the prefix 'Cream' or 'Creamy'. Reminds me of Berrynose.

[ephemera etcetera]

apologies if this seems like spam but keep in mind that erin hunter, although she wrote the series, doesn't always pick traditional names and in the later books seemed to be just scrambling for names that sounded pretty and not like something following the cat's normal rules
therefore I rate names that were in the books just as harshly it has nothing to do with the fact that they were in the books
I did say I was being harsh and very traditional so you can be creative all you want without counting my opinion but for just a regular cat in a regular clan I think those rules/tips I was talking about would likely apply (however that is not always the case)
however those just come from what I've read and things I've noticed so of course it is not the word of god
but please don't use "it was in the books" as defense
also sun, moon, etc. can be okay sometimes as long as they describe what the cat looks like I was just giving a reason for why it might not be the best choice for any normal kit
also it's okay for you to have a cat character who has the same name as one that is in the books, there's more than one "alex" or "jenny" in the human world so cat names don't have to be unique, just fitting
and one more thing, I'm not trying to ruin your fun and my opinions aren't the only ones that matter so go nuts, have fun with your fictional kitties
do you understand? I'm not going to clog the thread any more so PM me if you still wish to know the reasons behind my ratings

and here are some names for you to rate so this post wasn't a total waste of your time

Adderfang - grey-brown tabby she-cat elder with a lot of bite to her words. was above average in her hunting and fighting skills in her time.
Cherrycloud - tortoiseshell she-cat, doesn't show her emotions much but when she does they are usually toned down and gentle
Troutwhisker - light brown spotted tom with keen hunting skills, a bit of a coward in battle however
Lightningtail - energetic white-cream tom with a light build, quick and agile, very good at ambushing both prey and cats

[EO+RS]

Adderfang- 8/10, mostly original
Cherrycloud- 6/10 less original, but sounds good
Troutwhisker- 8/10 good
Lightningtail- 8/10 half original, sounds like a pikachu

Mine: Dawnshade
Lakejump
Blazingsoul
Flamingspirit
Flickerstep

[epimetheus]

{5 names max, guys!}

[EO+RS]

Sorry!

[.Fish.]

Mine: Dawnshade 6/10 I like it
Lakejump 5/10 It sound a bit weird to me
Blazingsoul 8/10 Sounds very unquie
Flamingspirit 6/10 Nice
Flickerstep 7/10 Very cretive

Rockfire
Roseheart
Greyheart
Bramlefur
Whitefang

[epimetheus]

Mine: Dawnshade
Lakejump
Blazingsoul
Flamingspirit
Flickerstep

Dawnshade-9/10-I've never heard this before-Very original-
Lakejump-7/10-Sounds like they're jumping into a lake-but still very original-
Blazingsoul-10/10-I love this, never heard before!-Very original-
Flamingspirit-7/10-Flow is a bit off, but pretty-Very original-
Flickerstep-10/10-I love this, never heard before!-Very original-

-My Awesome Warriors Names-

Flamingnose
Dewspots
Rabbitfang
Raccoonstripe
Graysong

[epimetheus]

Rockfire
Roseheart
Greyheart
Bramlefur
Whitefang

Rockfire-10/10-Never heard it before, love it!-Very original-
Roseheart-8/10-A bit common, but overall a pretty name-Great flow-
Greyheart-7/10-A bit plain, but I haven't heard it before-Good flow-
Bramblefur-7/10-See above name-Reminds me of Bramblestar, one of my favorites!-
Whitefang-10/10-I love this, never heard before!-Also a name of a book-

Nightsong
Jaguarsong
Ebonysong
Icesong
Leopardsong

[EO+RS]

Flamingnose-8/10-flow is a bit off, but good.
Dewspots- 10/10-very pretty name
Rabbitfang-9.9/10-great name, flow is a hair off
Raccoonstripe-8/10- a little hard to say quickly, doesn't flow quite right.
Graysong- 9/10- good name, nice flow, but doesn't sound...quite...there, if y'know what I mean...


Nightsong-9/10- very good, night-- is a bit overused
Jaguarsong-9/10- flow is off, jaguar-- makes it hard to say
Ebonysong- 9/10- those two words don't fit together.
Icesong-9/10- pretty, elegant, but two s-sounds together.
Leopardsong- 10/10- I love this one.

Graydawn
Brackenburn

[mare.]

Nothing was there for me to rate so...

Cloudswipe - Cloud~Swipe - A gray and white patched Tom with light blue eyes
Owlstep - Owl~Step - A dark tortiseshell she-cat with deep amber eyes
Stormsky - Storm~Sky - A dark gray Tom with flashy silver eyes
Swallowtail - Swallow~Tail - A brown and white calico Tom with blue eyes
Firleaf - Fir~Leaf - A coppery golden Tom with amber eyes