The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Sweetie Bell]

Would this be fair?

[aye;]

Blue UR Cat = 2008 july pps? If no, what need to be added to make the trade fair?

The 2012 Blue UR Cat is equal to a Red Toxic. It's unfair to the July PPS.

[bvrd]

Would this be fair?

unfair to them

[Umbrellas]

Blue UR Cat = 2008 july pps? If no, what need to be added to make the trade fair?

The 2012 Blue UR Cat is equal to a Red Toxic. It's unfair to the July PPS.

We don't know what it's equal to yet. We're not even going to discuss putting it on the Rares List until November 2013.
But I'm 99% sure it's not going to be equal to a July PPS, so yes, unfair to the PPS.

[fuego-wolf]

Thanks for the reply.

Again, would this be better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2qCXZpltew

Thanks again.

[aye;]

I now have ten auction bids for my UR pot. Any opinions on which is the fairest?

-Bid 1
-Bid 2
-Bid 3
-Bid 4
-Bid 5
-Bid 6
-Bid 7
-Bid 8
-Bid 9
-Bid 10

3, 9 and 7 look the best in my eyes, but it also depends on the outcome of the toxic, get a second opinion

So any other opinions...?

The UR Pot is worth a Non-Coon, which is over the big gap, and it takes at least 3 sorbets to get over the big gap, so whichever is closest to the Non-Coon or even over would be good. I would say either Bid #3 or Bid #10 are the best.

[Sweetie Bell]

Would this be fair?

unfair to them

Thanks (:

[Phoenix]

Need a little help here.
I know that the Medium Speckled Rat is on the "Main Rares" list and the Red Rose Dog is "only" on the September list. But I don't know how high the demand for the rat is...

[aye;]

We don't know what it's equal to yet. We're not even going to discuss putting it on the Rares List until November 2013.
But I'm 99% sure it's not going to be equal to a July PPS, so yes, unfair to the PPS.

Oh okay, what I've been told on Xat Chat for fair trades, is:
2012 UR Blue Cat = Red Toxic
2012 UR Dog = Non-Coon
2012 UR Pot = Non-Coon

[Segie]

Which bid is better? I am auctioning my 2012 UR Dog.
Bid One
Bid 2
Does the growing white july have good demand?