The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Neku]

May Lion for Card Dog(s)? x: (I'm always so confused about Card Dog rarities cuz they're only Uncommon but 08's x_X Why must my hoard be so complicated)

I'd say unfair to card dogs. I think you could get one or two, but not the whole set.

Ah, that's what I meant ^^;! I the reason I put the 's' was because I was wondering if it would be worth any, and if so, how many. But it's worth at least one?

[Jeweled]

VR Birthday Tess Horse for Rare Red Rose Dog?

Unfair to the horse.

Very rare Halloween PPS 2009 for very rare Shima butterfly wolf.

Unfair to the PPS.

pink ballloon, gearback tribalx2, be galaxy, ce galaxy, line tribal, all four cake dogs, blue eyed advent, non jewel, ur dog, non balloon, august 08 lime green rat

for

moonswirl

If not fair, what to add/ take away?

I believe that's overpaying for the swirl. It's hard to tell since I'm better at judging things when I can see it visually - can you post a picture?

May Lion for Card Dog(s)? x: (I'm always so confused about Card Dog rarities cuz they're only Uncommon but 08's x_X Why must my hoard be so complicated)

A whole set? I would say one or two at most.

A rare september 08 (this one to be exact ) for a may lion? I know it's unfair to the 08, I want to know what should be added to make it fair :3

Still need advice =)

You need a few 09 rares, or an 08 advent.

[Atwood]

(VR)

for

(VR) and (R)?

[Minaethiel]

Thanks Jeweled :3

[Jeweled]

(VR)

for

(VR) and (R)?

Unfair to the pink bwolf. It's actually worth a September like the skele PPS. (Or at least that was agreed on in the Rares Guide thread. x3)

[Atwood]

Thanks, Jeweled - I thought it was a bit high a price for the rat. :3

[Vluaaq]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=832674

for all the android dogs?

[:)HeartsLovePeace<3]

and


for a moonswirl

[Vluaaq]

I think that might be an over offer for the moonswirl... Not sure ><

[skeleighton]

I think that might be an over offer for the moonswirl... Not sure ><

I think so too, but only by a little...so maybe remove a few of the commons/uncommons? Not sure, though.