The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Ancient Fairy Dragon]

Would Growing White July = UR Cat from this year?

[e.mbr]

Line tribal + ? = Joker

[Linja]

Is it better to trade the Brown Cookie for the Pink Grinner than for a Celestial PPS Pup, although the Grinners have a bad demand?
Which demand have the Celestial PPS?

grinners have low demand according to some. but I was offered fair trades and overpay a few times when I had one for trade. if you stick it out, and wont take less than fair, you can easily trade it off for a fair trade.

Thank you so much! And for what do you traded your Grinner then?
Okay, and which demand has the Celestial PPS?

[deer;;]

fair? if not what needs to be added?

[WolfSpore]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22981604&userid=31221&signature=cM5mrNd7CeRcTmPdOWWF7g


FAIR????

unless I missed something im pretty sure its unfair to them but I would get a second opinion :3

Agreed.

[Dalek]

Anyways, I've been working out a trade for someone's UR cat, and I want to see if it's fair right now, or what would need to be added or removed from either side. This is the trade as it is now. Is it fair, or would I need to add to or remove from my side?

[AquilaFuga]

Would Growing White July = UR Cat from this year?

Right now with the demand of the UR, yes.
When it dies down a bit, the GWJ could be a slight overpayment.

[Penultima]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eTx_YDMn7g

For the timberwolf?

[tenshi&akuma]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q7Krk4a5XA
Is this ok for the omgsr plains zebra

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22981604&userid=31221&signature=cM5mrNd7CeRcTmPdOWWF7g


FAIR????

unless I missed something im pretty sure its unfair to them but I would get a second opinion :3

its unfair to the bottom
the tess horse and the zombie horse and maybe the rat would have been fine

Is it better to trade the Brown Cookie for the Pink Grinner than for a Celestial PPS Pup, although the Grinners have a bad demand?
Which demand have the Celestial PPS?

grinners have low demand according to some. but I was offered fair trades and overpay a few times when I had one for trade. if you stick it out, and wont take less than fair, you can easily trade it off for a fair trade.

Thank you so much! And for what do you traded your Grinner then?
Okay, and which demand has the Celestial PPS?

I was able to get two mid advents and a few 09 rares. which was offered to me out of the blue.
two mid advents alone would be fair, so they overpaid a bit.

the celestial has good demand I believe ^^