The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22556707&userid=116138&signature=p62ngb5NftHqrNCE9iCZwA

Fair demand wise?

rarity wise unfair to them
I dont think demand wise its fair either. even though the eat me has high demand, it doesnt make up for the low advent+ difference

[typewriter,]

]

Is this fair?
I'm not really sure at this point.

]

Unfair to you.

Actually. It is unfair to the rares.

A high advent, which the non jeweled lion tail is, (low high advent) is worth seven or so good '09 rare pets. The user offered four good mid '09 rares and then one mid late '09 rare and two late '09 rares. Then of course the 2012 rare. The uncommons combined with the mid-late '09 rare and late rares dosnt quite fit the gap.

[e.mbr]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22556707&userid=116138&signature=p62ngb5NftHqrNCE9iCZwA

Fair demand wise?

rarity wise unfair to them
I dont think demand wise its fair either. even though the eat me has high demand, it doesnt make up for the low advent+ difference

I don't understand. Can you reword that, Sorry DX

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

A high advent, which the non jeweled lion tail is, (low high advent) is worth seven or so good '09 rare pets. The user offered four good mid '09 rares and then one mid late '09 rare and two late '09 rares. Then of course the 2012 rare. The uncommons combined with the mid-late '09 rare and late rares dosnt quite fit the gap.

its a mid advent. not a high.
the lowest line of the advent list is worth 2-3 march/april 09 rares.
after that the gaps go from a late 09 rare to a few uncommons.
I have gone through it all with DD. and we both agreed 7 mid-late 09 rares would be fine for one.
4 early 09 rares and 3 mid-late makes it fair if not unfair to them.

[e.mbr]

A high advent, which the non jeweled lion tail is, (low high advent) is worth seven or so good '09 rare pets. The user offered four good mid '09 rares and then one mid late '09 rare and two late '09 rares. Then of course the 2012 rare. The uncommons combined with the mid-late '09 rare and late rares dosnt quite fit the gap.

its a mid advent. not a high.
the lowest line of the advent list is worth 2-3 march/april 09 rares.
after that the gaps go from a late 09 rare to a few uncommons.
I have gone through it all with DD. and we both agreed 7 mid-late 09 rares would be fine for one.
4 early 09 rares and 3 mid-late makes it fair if not unfair to them.

I'm going to get a second opinion. thanks tho

[salmondragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22556350&userid=370322&signature=m8sdR3voGZW42mExyVmyjw

Fair? Thanks for your help, if you can help me that is. xD

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

A high advent, which the non jeweled lion tail is, (low high advent) is worth seven or so good '09 rare pets. The user offered four good mid '09 rares and then one mid late '09 rare and two late '09 rares. Then of course the 2012 rare. The uncommons combined with the mid-late '09 rare and late rares dosnt quite fit the gap.

its a mid advent. not a high.
the lowest line of the advent list is worth 2-3 march/april 09 rares.
after that the gaps go from a late 09 rare to a few uncommons.
I have gone through it all with DD. and we both agreed 7 mid-late 09 rares would be fine for one.
4 early 09 rares and 3 mid-late makes it fair if not unfair to them.

I'm going to get a second opinion. thanks tho

this wasnt in response to your trade.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22556350&userid=370322&signature=m8sdR3voGZW42mExyVmyjw

Fair? Thanks for your help, if you can help me that is. xD

looks unfair to them technically

[Cornishninja]

Halp D:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 76FKCuq6qw

Is the difference between the heavily speckled ratty and the wood angel so huge that it would take a ton of 2008-2009 VR/Rs AND three very high advent lists, as well as a royal bobtail to make it up? I mean there was a big jump... but is it THAT big? need advice here please?

[Veja]

Nevermind.

[sinnadaddy]

Fair?1
2
3