The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Halsin]

Pink Ballon + Dark Leapord = NonBalloon? Fair or not fair? C:

I would like to know too thanks :3

[Not me nope]

Fair?

[Angel Daiyu]

Trade One
Trade Two
Trade Three

I need someone who knows the Rares list very well (I'm looking out for specific users to answer as well; will not tell which ones), and I need more than one person answering (as I'll be able to pick my answer from what the majority picks.

Also, keep in mind that the cerbs are all the good fodder I have left (I have 2 orange and 1 red), and while one of the offers has one of my dreamies, I'm trying to climb to another pet so I can get ALL my dreamies as opposed to having just one.

Should I go for any of these trades?

I got 2 opinions on it so far. I need a couple more

[Banter.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22527765&userid=290&signature=iojdNZy2jQdum7qcvWrO_Q

Is this fair? Sorry if pet for item trades do not belong here, I didn't see anything mentioned about it in the rules..
Thanks in advance!

[RenaiRoa]

A Raven Dog for this group :
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=367101 ?

I don't think so yet, what else could I add to make it fair?

[Furiouswolf]

would this be fair? are the uncommon pets making up for the month gap between the rares? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ETvkIgtyHQ

[bnom]

Is this fair? I don't know about items ^-^

[Halsin]

Pink Ballon + Dark Leapord = NonBalloon? Fair or not fair? C:

I would like to know too thanks :3

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Trade One
Trade Two
Trade Three

I need someone who knows the Rares list very well (I'm looking out for specific users to answer as well; will not tell which ones), and I need more than one person answering (as I'll be able to pick my answer from what the majority picks.

Also, keep in mind that the cerbs are all the good fodder I have left (I have 2 orange and 1 red), and while one of the offers has one of my dreamies, I'm trying to climb to another pet so I can get ALL my dreamies as opposed to having just one.

Should I go for any of these trades?

The third is unfair to them; they need to add about another late '09 rare and then a mid '09 rare that has good demand. :3

1. unfair to them. by at least another low main list
2. unfair to them by 2 mid advents, technically
3. unfair to them by a few rares

personally I would take the first. its a huge overpay, and toxics have decent demand.
its a much better trade up than the other two

[Hekomi]

would this be fair? are the uncommon pets making up for the month gap between the rares? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ETvkIgtyHQ

It's not too bad. I'd say about fair.