The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Seykoon]

Please help! is this fair?

Looks very unfair to the bw...
But please get a second opinion as always

Still need help with this:
Was it good to accept this?

[Calix]

Guys, don't give false advice. That b-wolf is an advent and bottom tiered advents are worth 3-4 09 rares. It's unfair to the bwolf.

Seykoon- Unfair to you.

[Seykoon]

Guys, don't give false advice. That b-wolf is an advent and bottom tiered advents are worth 3-4 09 rares. It's unfair to the bwolf.

Seykoon- Unfair to you.

That's whate everybody said, very unfair to them, because they only got offerd the bw ? Sorry, but I understood it like this... ^^

Oh nou, very unfair to me, or just a bit, since the banner dog maybe will become a rare, and the white wolf too? o.o

[CalicoWolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nkx-WsBBbg
Please help, really need some help.

[Julia]

Fair?
I'd love some advice from educated item traders. Thank you! c:

& what would you say to this? I think the staff dogs will turn very common & common. (the last year's are all common I believe

Thanks to the answers so far c:

[Seykoon]

Fair?
I'd love some advice from educated item traders. Thank you! c:

& what would you say to this? I think the staff dogs will turn very common & common. (the last year's are all common I believe

Thanks to the answers so far c:

Items guide is your friend
Just look it up, it's pretty easy ^^
To me it looks unfair to them, but I'm not sure what the rose is worth, bot I think two of them are worth a '09 rare and the others a '10, or something like that....

I'm not sure about the second one, sorry.

[Riku_Kaida]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21547120&userid=240104&signature=7HFMgVxg7LqR-zLsFKu-9w

Pretty sure I know the answer but...fair?

[Julia]

Fair?
I'd love some advice from educated item traders. Thank you! c:

& what would you say to this? I think the staff dogs will turn very common & common. (the last year's are all common I believe

Thanks to the answers so far c:

Items guide is your friend
Just look it up, it's pretty easy ^^
To me it looks unfair to them, but I'm not sure what the rose is worth, bot I think two of them are worth a '09 rare and the others a '10, or something like that....

I'm not sure about the second one, sorry.

I know the item guide well, but I'd like some opinion if it's fair regarding demand etc. Thanks for your opinion, though (: !

I think it's quite hard to say if the second one is fair or not, since they're all ungrown... well, I think I'll just wait some time 'til the first ones are grown.

[Haru]

That else needs to be added to make it fair for both sides?
(If there is anything that needs to be added.)

[Seykoon]

@Julia:
*stares at signature* *can't stop staring*
Okay, you you a rainbow smoothie... okay, I believe you xD

Sorry ^^
I traded for the valentine items several times, and I think they are pretty easy to get, I would offer '08/'09 VR for them ^^

And I agree with you, it's really hard to say, I woudn't accepts or wait...