The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Julia]

These trades are making me anxious, I'd like some opinions. 8D
~1
Actually, I think it's unfair to me. What do you think?

~2
Seems alright, little unfair to them. Not sure whether to go for it or not.

~3
The dog with the eyes isn't worth that much, is it?

-Julia

[Itsike]

Is this fair? 75 very common/common '12 rats + these ones for Nick Cake Dog. Thank you in advance!

[addicted.]

uhm.. fair?

very, very unfair to them. o-o

[arabmorgan]

Is this fair? Not too good when it comes to items :c

[Julia]

Is this fair? 75 very common/common '12 rats + these ones for Nick Cake Dog. Thank you in advance!

Unfair to the Nick cake dog. I wouldn't go for it, at least. 75 '12 rats don't fill the gap, the rare rats have no real demand. So the trade is mainly the Scarf dog, malk wolf and the ice pps. It's actually not that bad, but I don't think the malk wolf and ice pps are filling the gap. Not sure about the ice pps' demand, though. You better get a second opinion, the more I think about it, the more confusing it is. I wouldn't go for it, still. 8D

[Sykhe]

These trades are making me anxious, I'd like some opinions. 8D
~1
Actually, I think it's unfair to me. What do you think?

~2
Seems alright, little unfair to them. Not sure whether to go for it or not.

~3
The dog with the eyes isn't worth that much, is it?

-Julia

I'm unsure about #1.
#2 seems like they're overpaying just a bit. If I'm correct the headphone dog is in higher demand.
#3 seems fair to me as the munchkin and non-Hallo pony are both VC.

[Julia]

Is this fair? Not too good when it comes to items :c

Unfair to you (:

@LilMissMurderous, thanks for your opinion!

[Grace & Ria]

Is this fair? Also, whats the demand on this Bun? (Looking to trade up)

[Itsike]

Is this fair? 75 very common/common '12 rats + these ones for Nick Cake Dog. Thank you in advance!

Unfair to the Nick cake dog. I wouldn't go for it, at least. 75 '12 rats don't fill the gap, the rare rats have no real demand. So the trade is mainly the Scarf dog, malk wolf and the ice pps. It's actually not that bad, but I don't think the malk wolf and ice pps are filling the gap. Not sure about the ice pps' demand, though. You better get a second opinion, the more I think about it, the more confusing it is. I wouldn't go for it, still. 8D

I was wondering if the trade's so horrible no one would consider it ._. Going to send a suggestion now, thank you so much!^^

[NocturnalPanda]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21299960&userid=27857&signature=cugTj6FVMExV94KmrFouhQ

ive been told its unfair to me, any idea what should be added to their side?
kinda urgent, thanks

I would say another high september and another mid advent

thanks so much!!