The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[nagema]

Is this fair for my Cerberus??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EZ6TpX-pnw

Nagema

Sorry, but I really need a reply as soon as possible.. thanks. ♥

[Pear]

Is this fair for my Cerberus??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EZ6TpX-pnw

Nagema

Sorry, but I really need a reply as soon as possible.. thanks. ♥

I would say it's overpay, but definitely get another opinion. c:

[Ravenevermore]

Would this be fair?
Thank you!

[Zeriath]

Would these two be a fair trade for a Blue Balloon?

[Pear]

Would this be fair?
Thank you!

I'd say it's a tinge of overpay since they are on the same tier. c:

Grey Border Collie, Brown Border Collie, Brown Cookie, Pink Cookie, Dark Grey Tag husky, Vixen, Celestial PPS, Bone PPS, Desert/Orange-swirl PPS, Heart PPS, Light Grey Speckled husky, B&W Pointy-eared Border Collie, Ice Blue Swirl, Blue Flower dog, Purple Star bobtail, Purple Heart/Husky, Mustard Heart/Husky, Cream Advent, Pale Pink/Blue-spotted, Pink Heart, Hollyfox Dog, Boar PPS, Dice PPS, Jeweled Liontail, Nonjewel Liontail

Would these two be a fair trade for a Blue Balloon?

No, neither of them are even on the advent list, and the Balloon is on the main list. c:

[saorsa-]

Would these two be a fair trade for a Blue Balloon?

Unfair to blue balloon.

[Luna_Rosso]

For my trade suggestion I am offering my Coontail for the UR Dog & the White Punk from 2010. My trading partner and Myself are still at a slight stalemate because even we are not sure if this is fair. We both value the pets very much, but we would like some second opinions. I believe it is fair due to the Coontail being so high on the main rares list, and the UR + Punk adds up to be the equivalent of such. But I will allow for you all to be the judge. Thank you all very much!!

Pet I'm Offering

Pets in Return

2008 Very Rare Coontail

2010 Very Rare White Punk + 2009 Very Rare UnReleased Dog

[Pedri Nanezgani]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i-3ZoXf5vg

Is this fair to my sleipnir?

[Pear]

What needs to be changed to make this fair, if it is not already? Thank you<3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Oce41uGN9w



How about this? c: (Without the PPS)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y91254_x6A


And this? x3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WnNkVzlxuQ

This too please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... U5sT2UL2DQ

[/quote]

[Pedri Nanezgani]

@Pear : I know the 2nd and 3rd trades are unfair to you...