The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[RainbowPeanut]

Was this fair? ;u; http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZXh6vW8zeA

[Fat Unicorn]

Was this fair? ;u; http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZXh6vW8zeA

It was unfair to them ~

[da .pimp. is here]

This [167 tokens] or a Palomino Tess Horse instead for the 167 tokens?
Based on rarity & demand which of the two are better?
Thank you.

[Papuru Tora]

Here are two trades I've gotten. Are they fair? Which is the better offer?

Trade 1

Trade 2

Both are unfair to them, but the better offer depends on what you prefer: demand or technical stuff. Technically, the first is the best, demandwise, the second is the best.

Hmmm... ok thanks!

[Masquarade]

This [167 tokens] or a Palomino Tess Horse instead for the 167 tokens?
Based on rarity & demand which of the two are better?
Thank you.

Unfair to you.

[atmos, bro.]

How many 09 rares would be fair for ?
Thank you!

Edit:
Also would this be a smart move?

[da .pimp. is here]

This [167 tokens] or a Palomino Tess Horse instead for the 167 tokens?
Based on rarity & demand which of the two are better?
Thank you.

2nd opinion please?

[Resin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21034432&userid=241831&signature=BJv0j50Fmk-F0af3cDYgwg

Does this seem fair? For some reason I feel that the Koi should be worth a bit more than the dog.

[nervousnickel]

This [167 tokens] or a Palomino Tess Horse instead for the 167 tokens?
Based on rarity & demand which of the two are better?
Thank you.

2nd opinion please?

I would think the Pink September... But I would definitely get another opinion on that.



Not too sure about this trade. I know they are all rats, but.. The blue ice rat is toward the top of the September list. The flower/toxic rat is toward the bottom of the September list and I don't believe the other rat is on the rares list at all.

I keep holding out on the hope that I'll be able to trade my Blue Ice Rat up one line to a Black Advent, but that seems to be a lost cause..

[Fat Unicorn]

Not too sure about this trade. I know they are all rats, but.. The blue ice rat is toward the top of the September list. The flower/toxic rat is toward the bottom of the September list and I don't believe the other rat is on the rares list at all.

I keep holding out on the hope that I'll be able to trade my Blue Ice Rat up one line to a Black Advent, but that seems to be a lost cause..

Yeah, that's unfair to you.