The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Umbrellas]

Pink patchy september + White lolita dog + Red Target dog = Red rose?(The red rose is mine)

That would be overpay for the Red Rose

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20968500&userid=170930&signature=xXf6i85nqAKBZDjp_4a4hQ

An edit of an earlier trade. Is it fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PKiHjYqpFA

And is this fair?

Both look unfair to the top, though it's hard to judge token value because right now they are in demand, but after Halloween they will be close to worthless.

[Falkenfire]

Banned Ghost + '10 uncommon = Tree Banner?

[Umbrellas]

Banned Ghost + '10 uncommon = Tree Banner?

2010 uncommon should be fine for the Tree Banner alone, but you'd be hard pressed to get one for that little given demand.
So it'd be unfair to the Banned Ghost's side

[Falkenfire]

Banned Ghost + '10 uncommon = Tree Banner?

2010 uncommon should be fine for the Tree Banner alone, but you'd be hard pressed to get one for that little given demand.
So it'd be unfair to the Banned Ghost's side

I know. I just wanted to see if it was even fair >.<''

What could be added taking away the Banned Ghost?

[RainbowPeanut]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jVcvzOMFcg ? ;u;

[Umbrellas]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21029288&userid=320742&signature=pAMAy99N82kujVcvzOMFcg ? ;u;

Very unfair to the top

[SilverPersimmon]

Whats a fair add to the redX for the rat?

And is this close to fair?

Main rare list....I'll understand it one day...Please and thank you. If you could tell me how to make them fair that would be wonderful as well.

[Umbrellas]

Whats a fair add to the redX for the rat?

And is this close to fair?

Main rare list....I'll understand it one day...Please and thank you. If you could tell me how to make them fair that would be wonderful as well.

1) You should add a highish September
2) Still unfair to the Green Toxic, by a mid September

[SilverPersimmon]

Whats a fair add to the redX for the rat?

And is this close to fair?

Main rare list....I'll understand it one day...Please and thank you. If you could tell me how to make them fair that would be wonderful as well.

1) You should add a highish September
2) Still unfair to the Green Toxic, by a mid September

Thank you~

About how many mid advents would equal a mid sept?

[Umbrellas]

About how many mid advents would equal a mid sept?

It's about four for a Pink Patchy, and Cake dogs go for about six. So depending upon the pet, 4-6 mid advents for a mid September