The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[bear]

I've got a few trades that I'm not sure about and would like some help c:

What needs to be added to their side to be fair?

Bid for my sunback auction - fair?
Another bid - fair?

Thank you c:

[ChocolateGryphon]

im desperately looking for someone who wants a nonswirl from my friend. my friend wants to downtrade fairly. which means she wants a few lower value pets that equal the nonswirl. she said maybe 3 sorbets or something, but are there other combinations of pets that make up a nonswirl pretty evenly? im not nessesarily looking for answers like "100 2010 rares" or "50 2009 very rares" but you can include combinations that are very high in quantity C:
thank you so much for consideration and time.

This may be wrong, but I'm mostly testing my knowledge and you should get another opinion. ^^

Non = 3 sorbets
Sorbet = 3 balloon dogs
Balloon dogs = 5 high septs?

So she could get 3 sorbets, or 9 balloon dogs (though I'm sure that'd be an unpleasant search) or 45 septembers? Definitely not 100% on that last one, but usually it's easier to trade for high values then trade those down, like 3 sorbets, then trade those for balloons or whatever, etc.

thank you i will keep this in mind!
i dont take your knowledge for granted, but i will investigate a little more here to figure out if a balloon dog equals 5 septembers and what 5 spetembers equal, and onward.

[Lotus Rose]

I've got a few trades that I'm not sure about and would like some help c:

What needs to be added to their side to be fair?

Bid for my sunback auction - fair?
Another bid - fair?

Thank you c:

Not sure about the others ones, but the last bid on the sun back is overpay ^^

[St✰r Angel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20712227&userid=246427&signature=zKtvFXq3CDxjRq6dxvY0lQ

Fair?

Oh or this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20712261&userid=246427&signature=vdU-tjOC11Ap40Zso7blCA

[tawnypelt3]

With demand, is a desert/orange swirl PPS and a 2009 rare Christmas dog fair for a grey border collie?

The PPS and collie are on the same line of the Rares List, but I want to know that my offer is completely fair with demand before I send it.

[ChocolateGryphon]

does one balloon dog equal 5 high septembers?

and what does 1 high september equal if you downtrade fairly?

and what does that equal downtraded, etc

[Maddy]

I received multiple trade requests for the same animal - which is best? (I suppose this is asking for better, instead of more fair, but I couldn't find another topic to place it in)

1) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20699435&userid=376585&signature=j2TDyWWhmbHbrWLgtMdutA
2) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20678616&userid=376585&signature=J4APzocneOTLMpqvSyZ7hA
3) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20677507&userid=376585&signature=5zrpA5G_wSb10O2qyxOVmw
4) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20711038&userid=376585&signature=cgVlZB7u60LGuwnoPVVj1g
5) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20711155&userid=376585&signature=mVE7_tJ4Dt1lS_HAtC2UAg

My apologies if this is obvious - I am very new here.

#2 and #3 are giving you store pets, which cost C$, so they are better on your part.
#3 isn't available anymore, and a dog, so it's of higher value than the pet in #2.
So in short I think #3 is your best offer c:

[aystabre]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks c:

[*Aquatic Monkey*]

Idk I think you might be overpaying

[Law]

Is this fair?

Meant to send it as a trade where I am overpaying, but it was edited down.
Just checking to see if I'm losing my grasp of CS rarities >.<