The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Umbrellas]

how fair is this>? I know each of the jackalopes is a mid 2010 rare but the fox in the trade isn't in high demand; still it's an early rare

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20445816&userid=247513&signature=EiKQN-y1GKrjbpXbliDE2A

Unfair to the jackalopes.

thank you, what needs to be added on their side?

Lateish '09 rare (from like September or so)

[neiroh]

Is this fair? I believe it isn't and I would really like to know what needs to be added. I would love a quick answer because it's very important.

[Umbrellas]

Is this fair? I believe it isn't and I would really like to know what needs to be added. I would love a quick answer because it's very important.

It looks unfair to you by a substantial amount

[neiroh]

Is this fair? I believe it isn't and I would really like to know what needs to be added. I would love a quick answer because it's very important.

It looks unfair to you by a substantial amount

Do you know by chance, how much should be added??
Like, would another Main List work? Like a Balloon Dog?

[Syberia]

these items http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ERJfRCIGGg for this '08 VR

Fair?

[Smamm]

For a green liontail. Fair?

Will tip knowledged helpers!

Lord no! Very unfair to you! That liontail you're offering alone is enough to compensate for a green liontail. ^^

[Chipchap]

Fair? if not, what can be added?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w07JrzY8pQ

[Sagaline]

What should be added to make this fair?

Any help appreciated (:

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

For a green liontail. Fair?

Will tip knowledged helpers!

Lord no! Very unfair to you! That liontail you're offering alone is enough to compensate for a green liontail. ^^

no it isnt. the green liontail is worth more than the other two.
its still unfair to bottom. but your reasoning is false.

[bnom]

For a green liontail. Fair?

Will tip knowledged helpers!

Lord no! Very unfair to you! That liontail you're offering alone is enough to compensate for a green liontail. ^^

I think the Liontail + a couple of '09 rares should be fair.