The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Umbrellas]

I know it's been cancelled, but demand and rarity, is this fair? -PS they sent it blank, I just edited. -
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... acp098dcWw

I would say unfair to the bottom; demand and rarity both into account.

this is unfair to the dog.
rarity wise its unfair. 4 uncommons =/= 09 rare
demand wise too. high demand 09 rare dog is worth more than some warriors.

They're 09' uncommons, though. I think 4 uncommons could equal up to a rare, no? A couple of those warriors are hard to come by now, aren't they? Or am I thinking of the wrong warriors. ono

Sortics are very high in demand
and '09 rares are usually pretty high in value. Those warrior cats are pretty easy to come by. So it'd be unfair to the sortic.

[Smamm]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20450302&userid=346209&signature=WzxN_7dq431-MSBpyh6teg

Fair?

It's hard to say. We can't really estimate the worth of the newborns in comparison... I suppose it depends on how bad they want those newborns (they could end up being worth a lot, or not...). ^^

[Smamm]

I would say unfair to the bottom; demand and rarity both into account.

this is unfair to the dog.
rarity wise its unfair. 4 uncommons =/= 09 rare
demand wise too. high demand 09 rare dog is worth more than some warriors.

They're 09' uncommons, though. I think 4 uncommons could equal up to a rare, no? A couple of those warriors are hard to come by now, aren't they? Or am I thinking of the wrong warriors. ono

Sortics are very high in demand
and '09 rares are usually pretty high in value. Those warrior cats are pretty easy to come by. So it'd be unfair to the sortic.

Ah, alright. xD I was probably thinking of the wrong warriors then. My fault. (I also have a good load of sortics from when they were released, so I didn't know they were in demand since no one ever wants to trade for mine. xD)

[Calix]

For a green liontail. Fair?

Will tip knowledged helpers!

[Demonking Urizen]

Would be a trade with 7 September '12 Outcomes (4 VC dogs, 2 C horses, 1 VC horse) fair for a Januar '11 Uncommon butterwolf? Thanks for advice!

This trade is it: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WpeX87YFAA

[Lynke]

I see >< I just don't know if its worth it. XD I like the cat... It's on my wish list. But I'm always so iffy on trading pets that aren't fully grown. Thank you for the input.

[Amailia11]

Would this Rares List trade be fair? What should I change if it isn't? Thanks in advance!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WKEL0U8Cgg

[Umbrellas]

Would this Rares List trade be fair? What should I change if it isn't? Thanks in advance!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WKEL0U8Cgg

I believe it is unfair to them

[Amailia11]

Would this Rares List trade be fair? What should I change if it isn't? Thanks in advance!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WKEL0U8Cgg

I believe it is unfair to them

Okay. Thank you. Does anybody have a 2nd opinion or what I should take off?

[ScuroFenice]

how fair is this>? I know each of the jackalopes is a mid 2010 rare but the fox in the trade isn't in high demand; still it's an early rare

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20445816&userid=247513&signature=EiKQN-y1GKrjbpXbliDE2A

Unfair to the jackalopes.

thank you, what needs to be added on their side? two people said another 2010 rare but early, mid or late?