The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Jeweled]

Me:
Advent '08 Horse
Rare Green and Orange Butterfly Wolf
Rare Purple and Green Rat

Them:
Strawberry PPS
Store PPS
Blue Panda Rat
Rare 12/18 Rat (not sure of the name)
Four Anniversary Cats
2010 Pup

Is this fair? If not, what should be added? (I have no more Rares to offer, though I would assume that this is not unfair to them at all.)

Can you post pictures? x3

My joker for both a green toxic and blue toxic?

Very unfair to the toxics.
Just the greeen would do.

[Tif + Jo]

My blue Dragon for Their Black Advent and Celestial 08 PPS?

[Megannator]

My blue Dragon for Their Black Advent and Celestial 08 PPS?

I would think, since the blue dragon will be released more (as I think they are supposed to be, along with the white and red ones?) it's unfair to the other side. I think just one of the advents would do...

[JadeiteWren]

http://i44.tinypic.com/30iwema.png
My rl friend said she'd trade me her Rainbow Mane if the trade was fair.

[Diabolic]

http://i44.tinypic.com/30iwema.png
My rl friend said she'd trade me her Rainbow Mane if the trade was fair.

Well, that is not fair for a Rainbow Mane.

[JadeiteWren]

http://i44.tinypic.com/30iwema.png
My rl friend said she'd trade me her Rainbow Mane if the trade was fair.

Well, that is not fair for a Rainbow Mane.

What else would need to be added?
Edit: I have a Wood Angel I could add to my side. o3o If I wanted to trade her the Wood Angel what else would have to be added.

[Diabolic]

http://i44.tinypic.com/30iwema.png
My rl friend said she'd trade me her Rainbow Mane if the trade was fair.

Well, that is not fair for a Rainbow Mane.

What else would need to be added?
Edit: I have a Wood Angel I could add to my side. o3o If I wanted to trade her the Wood Angel what else would have to be added.

The Rainbow Mane is still worth a common toxic. You have to add a bunch of 08 rares, advents, octobers, or a couple of septembers.

Wood Angel + a september would probably be fair.


EDIT// If even that. Actually I think you could get away with 2 advents + Wood Angel. Or two rare octobers. I'm not sure. The rainbow mane is a horse and horses are in general less liked/lower in value than dogs.

[Red Wolf]

A white dragon for a 2009 Cerberus?

[JadeiteWren]

So would this be a fair? (I suck at rarities that aren't dogs D8 )
http://i39.tinypic.com/a9v403.png
Edit: Remove one malk dog colored bunny. I accidentally added two of the same XD

[ZenonZogratis]

So would this be a fair? (I suck at rarities that aren't dogs D8 )
http://i39.tinypic.com/a9v403.png

That might be a little too much.