The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[KingsRansome]

Is this fair, thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4bLGp9bilw

Very un fair to you; all those unknowns will become commons and very commons

[Pideaux]

Does an uncommon Christmas 2010 bat equal 5 very common September '12 dogs + 1 common August '12 horse?
Thanks for advice!

Unfair to the bat, even with it's low demand. Here are some key points to keep in mind when trading like this:

2OMGSC = VC
2VC = Common
2 Common = Uncommon.

So 4 VC per Uncommon (same species, within three months dates)

4 Rarities (up to uncommon) per year separation.

So 4 2012 Uncommons = 1 2011 Uncommon. 16 2012 uncommons = 1 2010 uncommon. Etc.

These are rules I live by and they seem to go over well for both parties. :3

Just checking but is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1GoT384n2g

Unfair to you.

Most of the items are only worth a 2012 Common-Uncommon. Read above. :3

Is this fair, thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4bLGp9bilw

Unfair to you.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20423440&userid=2017&signature=FDo90wLBnM0_dXqq7jWEOQ

Is this fair..?

I want to say this is unfair to them, but get another opinion. I'm almost positive it is. :3

Is this fair? They originaly want all my 2011 pets and both my rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5TklvOJvJw

Unfair to them. A lot of those items are from last year.

[Allysun]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20423440&userid=2017&signature=FDo90wLBnM0_dXqq7jWEOQ

Is this fair..?

I want to say this is unfair to them, but get another opinion. I'm almost positive it is. :3

Alright, thanks! I figured it was, but I know the lion plush is worth an '09 rare, and I'm not sure about store values, so I was wanting to check. I'm awful with items values.


Second opinion, please?

[hellhunt]

Is it fair technically and demand vise?

[Umbrellas]

Is it fair technically and demand vise?

Unfair to you rarity and demandwise
Take out either the Nick Dog or Santa Cat on your side and replace it with an early '09 rare or so

[Pideaux]

Is it fair technically and demand vise?

Unfair to you imo. Demand wise, it's about equal since although 09 bunnies are hard to find, they don't have much demand behind them. But neither do yours, I don't believe. :3

[Amkorra]

hi there...
what would be needed to be added to a wolf pps to make it fair for the rose pps?

aka: Wolf PPS + ???? = Rose PPS

thanks for any answers ^^

[Corporate Cannibal]

is this trade fair? thanks guys! ^^

[GreatWhiteDragon_1]

is this trade fair? thanks guys! ^^

Unfair to Warrior cat. The Rainbow Drafts have very little/no demand.

[Corporate Cannibal]

is this trade fair? thanks guys! ^^

Unfair to Warrior cat. The Rainbow Drafts have very little/no demand.

thanks