The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[SagittariusII]

They offered:
Three Rare rats (All on my Wishlit)
Five Anniversary Cats (Hoard)

They want:
Advent '08 Horse
Rare Green and Orange Butterfly Wolf (October '09)
Rare Purple and Green Rat

I'd say pretty fair.

[mokapi]

My side: Dogtag
Their side: Non-jewel Sun, Line Tribal, Blue Balloon, and Sock advent.

Thanks for the help earlier. :3 /is always confused

If this isn't fair for me, would adding either a Blue Rose or a Sorbet help?
If it isn't fair for them, would taking off the Sock advent help?

I really appreciate all the answers I get. ;____; I know I ask a lot.

[Shai]

Christmas Bone PPS + Christmas dog with Holly in its mouth for http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=518230 ?

[Christy]

My side: Dogtag
Their side: Non-jewel Sun, Line Tribal, Blue Balloon, and Sock advent.

Thanks for the help earlier. :3 /is always confused

If this isn't fair for me, would adding either a Blue Rose or a Sorbet help?
If it isn't fair for them, would taking off the Sock advent help?

I really appreciate all the answers I get. ;____; I know I ask a lot.

I say adding the sorbet should make it fair

[mokapi]

Christmas Bone PPS + Christmas dog with Holly in its mouth for http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=518230 ?

Well...there's a lot of rares in that group but they are all '10s. I personally wouldn't let my advents go for those. :3

[mokapi]

My side: Dogtag
Their side: Non-jewel Sun, Line Tribal, Blue Balloon, and Sock advent.

Thanks for the help earlier. :3 /is always confused

If this isn't fair for me, would adding either a Blue Rose or a Sorbet help?
If it isn't fair for them, would taking off the Sock advent help?

I really appreciate all the answers I get. ;____; I know I ask a lot.

I say adding the sorbet should make it fair

Okay ^^; Any other opinions? :3

[Shai]

Christmas Bone PPS or Christmas dog with Holly in its mouth for http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=518230 ?

Well...there's a lot of rares in that group but they are all '10s. I personally wouldn't let my advents go for those. :3

I thought so, plus I meant to say or, not +...

[Shai]

My side: Dogtag
Their side: Non-jewel Sun, Line Tribal, Blue Balloon, and Sock advent.

Thanks for the help earlier. :3 /is always confused

If this isn't fair for me, would adding either a Blue Rose or a Sorbet help?
If it isn't fair for them, would taking off the Sock advent help?

I really appreciate all the answers I get. ;____; I know I ask a lot.

I say adding the sorbet should make it fair

Okay ^^; Any other opinions? :3

I'd say adding a sorbet may make it fair, but I don't have the greatest idea of rarities...

[mokapi]

Christmas Bone PPS or Christmas dog with Holly in its mouth for http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=518230 ?

Well...there's a lot of rares in that group but they are all '10s. I personally wouldn't let my advents go for those. :3

I thought so, plus I meant to say or, not +...

Maybe for the Fox advent...maybe. I adore my advents though :3 I only swap them for other advents xD

[huskynerd]

Christmas Bone PPS or Christmas dog with Holly in its mouth for http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=518230 ?

Well...there's a lot of rares in that group but they are all '10s. I personally wouldn't let my advents go for those. :3

I thought so, plus I meant to say or, not +...

The Celestial PPS (the blue one in your group) is an even swap for the bone PPS, so more would be overpaying. I've also been told that the KISS PPS is worth a common Advent, so that group may indeed be worth both the pets. It may even be overpaying by a tad. The Holly fox is pretty wanted but not that rare though, so I'm not quite sure with it.