The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[nucleareaction]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20423390&userid=306257&signature=3Ip2KMFlav-B4TUOXULwrw

I just got that dragon, and I have no idea how rare it is. How much of a gap is there? If I were to auction it do you think I could get that or better?

It's unfair to the dragon and I'm pretty sure you'd be able to get more than just a mid-advent for it ^^.

Thanks, what about this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SS-dH2GbcQ

[*HorseShoeImprints*]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ttnClZeqgQ

Fair or Not ? This is a Re-released Pet by the way ... and what do i need to add to make it fair???

[bvrd]

Would this be fair to my Blue Sorbet? ^^

[&& echo;]

Is this fair? Demand and list wise c:
Also, are they overpaying?? If not, what could they add?

[icseal]

Is this fair? Demand and list wise c:
Also, are they overpaying?? If not, what could they add?

It would be unfair to you, since you have a Mid September List over there, the user only has a high and a low advent.
The user should try adding a few more advents/rares.

[CSF]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ttnClZeqgQ

Fair or Not ? This is a Re-released Pet by the way ... and what do i need to add to make it fair???

Considering the demand right now for the bunnies, I would say unfair to them. Usually when store pets first come out they go for about an '09 rare each(or so that's what I observed). Please get another opinon though ^-^

[icseal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20426006&userid=85073&signature=zwaFtXDaC1htttnClZeqgQ

Fair or Not ? This is a Re-released Pet by the way ... and what do i need to add to make it fair???

1 2012 Store pet = 1 2009 Rare or 2010 Rare with a few Uncommons

You have a 2009 rare, so try adding two more 2009 rares c:

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this fair? Demand and list wise c:
Also, are they overpaying?? If not, what could they add?

It would be unfair to you, since you have a Mid September List over there, the user only has a high and a low advent.
The user should try adding a few more advents/rares.

its fair actually. please check the list before giving advice.
the eat me is a high advent.
the border collie is a mid advent and the marionette is a low. together the mid and low advent should be fair for the eat me.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20426006&userid=85073&signature=zwaFtXDaC1htttnClZeqgQ

Fair or Not ? This is a Re-released Pet by the way ... and what do i need to add to make it fair???

1 2012 Store pet = 1 2009 Rare or 2010 Rare with a few Uncommons

You have a 2009 rare, so try adding two more 2009 rares c:

that is quite false.
2012 store pets are worth a mid 2010 rare.
its slightly unfair to them. a mid-late 2010 rare should be added to the bottom.

[bvrd]

Would this be fair to my Blue Sorbet? ^^

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Would this be fair to my Blue Sorbet? ^^

very unfair to the blue sorb