The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

What is a Dark-Faced Growing October? And is it fair for a 2009 rare?

dark faced october is an 08 very rare. from, well.. october lol
Its worth more than an 09 rare. probably a bit less than a low advent

[bnom]

What is a Dark-Faced Growing October? And is it fair for a 2009 rare?

dark faced october is an 08 very rare. from, well.. october lol
Its worth more than an 09 rare. probably a bit less than a low advent

Ohh! Thanks ^^

[KoTsuki]

Hey Can anyone tell me if this is fair, and if not, to who?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u0v9k8MUfw

Thanks so much in advance! ^-^ <3

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Hey :) Can anyone tell me if this is fair, and if not, to who?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u0v9k8MUfw

Thanks so much in advance! ^-^ <3

unfair to them

[Umbrellas]

Hey Can anyone tell me if this is fair, and if not, to who?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u0v9k8MUfw

Thanks so much in advance! ^-^ <3

Looks unfair to them
The Sortic alone would be overpay, especially because they have very high demand
So the addition of the bat just makes it more unfair to them C:

[KoTsuki]

Hey Can anyone tell me if this is fair, and if not, to who?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u0v9k8MUfw

Thanks so much in advance! ^-^ <3

Looks unfair to them
The Sortic alone would be overpay, especially because they have very high demand
So the addition of the bat just makes it more unfair to them C:

Thankyou! Both of you guys for your help ^-^

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this fair? Oh and demand wise too :3

Thank you! I need lots of opinions on this, so just say what you think C:

rarity wise unfair to them. but only slightly
none of the pets[on either side] have much demand. so demand isnt really a swaying factor here

[galaxy.]

Is this fair? Oh and demand wise too :3

Thank you! I need lots of opinions on this, so just say what you think C:

rarity wise unfair to them. but only slightly
none of the pets[on either side] have much demand. so demand isnt really a swaying factor here

I was thinking that, so I'm not sure whether to auto or not :3 any other opinions?

[clarkal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20419128&userid=343527&signature=GSryBpJy0Yp_jP5Ta-dH7Q
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20419083&userid=343527&signature=fqPij5s-m8MaEXtNTsRihw

[Umbrellas]

Is this fair? Oh and demand wise too :3

Thank you! I need lots of opinions on this, so just say what you think C:

rarity wise unfair to them. but only slightly
none of the pets[on either side] have much demand. so demand isnt really a swaying factor here

I was thinking that, so I'm not sure whether to auto or not :3 any other opinions?

I agree that it's slightly unfair to the top
I don't think I'd auto that; it seems like a fair bid, but autos are usually overpay by a fair amount