add-on list, regarding nov/oct 08's, discussion thread.

[Fat Unicorn]

We have already discussed the Elemental Cats on the first page, I see no need to bring them up again. ;3

I just wanted to bounce something off you, DaDwarf:
Okay, people are going to be confused about the worth of the lowest advent tier and the new list. They'll probably think that you need several early '09 rares to jump up to the new list, rather than the advent list. Maybe Komi & you should clearly state the gap in between the two lists (this will save ~ t r o u b l e ~ and I a lot of questions on the FTT thread) and the worth of the new list on the actual post, near the top?

[DaDwarf]

We are also working on a gaps list, yes ^^, which will explain what is exactly the gap between tires, on all lists.

edit;

09's list

Royal bobtail, Fireworks PPS

Growing Light-Faced October, Blue Light Stripe, Orange Heavy Stripe, Growing Dark-Faced October, Watermelon Dog, Ying-Yang dog, Rose Rat, Dark Wood Dog, Bumblebee Spider,Malk PPS Pup

Jack-O-Lantern Rat, Panda rats, white scarf, Blue scarf

09 robot dog, card dogs

08 rats that are not on the list yet.

This is a rough draft i made up just now, tell me what you guys think? Anything need to be moved up, lower and what else needs to go where?

Figured we had to start somewhere xD

[Havoc Hyena]

I'm definitely casting my vote for the green nose rainbow dog, I get a lot of trades for the one in my trade group. I also see a lot of demand for the White Feb, Gold Robot dog, and for the striped flame Malk wolf, Dark Shepherd dog, Good and Evil GUPPS dogs I have get a lot of activity (but not as much recently as they used to), Blue merle Aussie PPS, and the adult Strawberry dog.

Also, I dunno if the Green Batdog has been mentioned or not, but when I had a few in my trades group I would get blown up with offers on them.

Sorry if some of these have been listed, I was just going off the top of my head.

Not really suggesting where they should be put, just listing some of the pets that I get a lot of trades for, I'll dig up some old trades to see what I'm being offered for them if it will help place them.

[nickjr]

Hm, I didn't think the Advent 09 GUPPSes were that valuable o.o except for maybe the Boar GUPPS, considering how he's already VR and turned rare over a year before the rest of the 09 GUPPSes.

[DaDwarf]

I honestly first want to work on placing the left over 08's on the list xD and from there we can slowly add the 09 very rares.

I do believe that if it's not 08 and just rare that it shouldn't be on the list. (With some exceptions ofc) things like the GUPPS..i don't see them on the list, they are not worth nearly as much as the 08 rares or even very rares.

[Solloby]

09's list

Royal bobtail, Fireworks PPS

Growing Light-Faced October, Blue Light Stripe, Orange Heavy Stripe, Growing Dark-Faced October, Watermelon Dog, Ying-Yang dog, Rose Rat, Dark Wood Dog, Bumblebee Spider,Malk PPS Pup

Jack-O-Lantern Rat, Panda rats, white scarf, Blue scarf

09 robot dog, card dogs

08 rats that are not on the list yet.

Does Royal Bob have tons of demand? He didn't turn VR until Oct '11, way after Yin Yang & Watermelon Dog etc.

Aren't the Panda Rats more popular than Rose Rat? And although I think Rose Rat is worth a bit more than Jack Rat, I'm not sure it's enough to put it on a different line.

Skeleton Rat should go on the line below Jack Rat though I think.

Regarding the Bumblebee Spider, I know someone who is looking for two, and offering overpay, but cannot find any. It turned VR in March 2010, with Scarf PPS. It's rarer than most September 08s, and Joker. I am thinking that if you want one, unless the rereleases have been affecting their quantity, that you will have to pay an 08 Advent just to find one. There just aren't any around. Yes there is no demand, but there's pretty much no supply either. It's the same story as those super hard rats (took me a little while to find Jack & Rose Rats) but with an even rarer pet.

[shadow by night]

this dog has very high demand, maybe even below the bottom tier, though. Littermate of inverted leopard

[vvoland]

Null PPS Perhaps?

[lucky333123]

Null PPS Perhaps?

I would think so, many users are after them.

Not sure if this has already been answered but the African Wild Dogs <-- the demand last time I checked was pretty high on them

[shadow by night]

Null PPS Perhaps?

Ys.. maybe put it


Royal bobtail, Fireworks PPS

Growing Light-Faced October, Blue Light Stripe, Orange Heavy Stripe, Growing Dark-Faced October, Watermelon Dog, Ying-Yang dog, Rose Rat, Dark Wood Dog, Bumblebee Spider,Malk PPS Pup

Jack-O-Lantern Rat, Panda rats, white scarf, Blue scarf
here?
09 robot dog, card dogs