"The" Rares List Guide - Do not ask about new UR's!

[XanthussMarduk]

Hmmm... So let's tweak the rarity list you made, Jeweled.
:3

Rarity list:

Sunjewel / Moonswirl / UR B-Wolf
Dogtag
Plains Zebra
Grevy's Zebra
Mountain Zebra
Banana
UR Cat / July PPS

It'd look like this in that case. C:

Oh, and, if you're making tweaks to the front post, can you change my username where you listed it? OCD here is being bothered by it. xD;

Rarity list:

Sunjewel / Moonswirl / UR B-Wolf / Dogtag
Plains Zebra
Grevy's Zebra
Mountain Zebra
Banana
UR Cat / July PPS

I think the Dogtag would be even with the Moonswirl and The sun jewel though i'm think the UR BW is the even rarer and is certainly the most in demand.

[huskynerd]

Hmmm... So let's tweak the rarity list you made, Jeweled.
:3

Rarity list:

Sunjewel / Moonswirl / UR B-Wolf
Dogtag
Plains Zebra
Grevy's Zebra
Mountain Zebra
Banana
UR Cat / July PPS

It'd look like this in that case. C:

Oh, and, if you're making tweaks to the front post, can you change my username where you listed it? OCD here is being bothered by it. xD;

I don't think the Dogtag belongs above the zebras and banana. If we're going by rarity the reason is obvious, but even when demand factors in - I was under the impression that the Dogtag wasn't even in that high demand compared to those other three.

[/humble opinion]

[Jeweled]

I don't think the Dogtag belongs above the zebras and banana. If we're going by rarity the reason is obvious, but even when demand factors in - I was under the impression that the Dogtag wasn't even in that high demand compared to those other three.

[/humble opinion]

I was under the impression that the list we were creating factored in both rarity and demand, but you're right, the tag should probably at least go beneath the zebras. x3

However, the tag, although statistically rarer than the jewel, swirl, and [possibly] the UR bwolf, is definitely not worth as much - you need to add to it in order to obtain those three. Sometimes as much as a balloon dog. That's why I did not put it even with them on the list.

[PolarAzulTigris]

I'm just curious, but what about the cake dogs? Perhaps they're not that rare as they're not here, but just curious.

[huskynerd]

I'm just curious, but what about the cake dogs? Perhaps they're not that rare as they're not here, but just curious.

I think they don't quite make it on. ^^

Speaking of, though, should the Skeleton PPS be on the list? It's worth about a common August, so maybe it would be above the Rose PPS?

[huskynerd]

Yeah, the CE is getting confusing to me. People are saying wildly different things.

I'm wondering if the list should go like this?

Green Sorbet
Blue Sorbet
Purple Toxic
Blue Toxic
Yellow Sorbet
Pink Sorbet
CE Galaxy
[Rest of the Toxics]

I'm really not sure about this, so perhaps someone more knowledgable could correct me? ^^

[Jeweled]

You know what, any guides of this kind are useless beacuse there are many players who don't agree with that.

Of course some people won't agree. But given the people who have contributed to this thread have their rarities down pat, it's probably pretty darn accurate. ^^

Yeah, the CE is getting confusing to me. People are saying wildly different things.

I'm wondering if the list should go like this?

Green Sorbet
Blue Sorbet
Purple Toxic
Blue Toxic
Yellow Sorbet
Pink Sorbet
CE Galaxy
[Rest of the Toxics]

I'm really not sure about this, so perhaps someone more knowledgable could correct me? ^^

The CE is tough to judge, but I've always placed it somewhere in the middle of the Augusts. Perhaps not that low, but somewhere in that list.

[huskynerd]

Is it worth more than the Blue/Purple Toxics though? Someone asked in what order were the toxics, galaxies, and sorbets placed. I though Toxics were generally worth less than Sorbets, and the CE fell somewhere in between the Blue/Green Sorbets and the Pink/Yellow ones. But I'm not so sure about those two rarest Toxics. :/

I defer to the expertise of this thread. XD

[Atwood]

The Black-eyed Galaxy is roughly equal to the Sorbets from what I've seen, so that might be what you're thinking of. The CE Galaxy is in between the Toxics, so the Blue/Purple Toxics are worth more and the others are worth less, and all are worth less than the Sorbets (the Blue/Purple Toxics might be on par with the Sorbets though, depending on who you ask). The CE is definitely worth more than a non-balloon though. The Joker is worth around a Non-Balloon, but that one tends to vary a fair bit depending on who you ask as well because of the high demand for Jokers.

Rough condensed list:

Sorbets = BE Galaxy
Purple/Blue Toxic
CE Galaxy
Other Toxics
Non-Balloon = Joker

[SagittariusII]

Shouldn't very rare July08 rats be on this list? I see a lot on the older players' wishlists.