The "Is this a fair trade?" thread [xat chat added]

[Dexter's Gal]

Is this trade fair? I'm aware that the Store Dog is a paperclip, I just want to make sure that it's more or less fair to me.

[sincerelyv]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867243&userid=250052&signature=CVOlfutKatggcUTgnVasNQ

Is this fair? I just want to get an opinion on it. Thanks!

Unfair to the black advent.

[Kuzco]

Is this trade fair? I'm aware that the Store Dog is a paperclip, I just want to make sure that it's more or less fair to me.

The store dog is worth a '10 rare, so it's not fair to you.

[kaseylu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867243&userid=250052&signature=CVOlfutKatggcUTgnVasNQ

Is this fair? I just want to get an opinion on it. Thanks!

Unfair to the black advent.

Okay thanks! Is there any way i could make it better? How many more rares or whatever should i add? Thanks!

[Nikki Amaranti]

Is a fair tradet?

Unfair to the top by a lot.
August lion is worth in rarity, any other 2012 Rare or a 2011 at most if overpay.

They're paying way too much.

^ - ^"

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867243&userid=250052&signature=CVOlfutKatggcUTgnVasNQ

Is this fair? I just want to get an opinion on it. Thanks!

Quite unfair the BA on the top. :3

[Kaliyana]

Is a fair tradet?

Very fair. Well very unfair to the other person.

Don't give advice like that. It's either unfair, or it's fair. It can't be both.
Extremely unfair to the other person.

What i meant, was it is fair, but yet at the same time it would be unfair to the other person. It is fair, but an overpay, but it is the other persons choice.

It can't be fair AND be an overpay that's my point. The trade is either fair, or unfair. Overpays are technically unfair to whomever is overpaying. Therefore, you can't say that the trade was fair to the person being offered the trade, and unfair to the person overpaying. It doesn't work that way.

Is this trade fair? I'm aware that the Store Dog is a paperclip, I just want to make sure that it's more or less fair to me.

The store dog is worth a '10 rare, so it's not fair to you.

Um... I was told a while ago, on either this thread or the one of the two before it that early store pets from this year were worth a late '09 rare.
When did that change?

EDIT:
Also, is this trade fair?

[sincerelyv]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867243&userid=250052&signature=CVOlfutKatggcUTgnVasNQ

Okay thanks! Is there any way i could make it better? How many more rares or whatever should i add? Thanks!

Rares? Quite a bit. O_o;

The BA is worth 8 mid-advents and there are 7 early 09 rares per mid-advent, so.
Quite a bit. (:

[kaseylu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... we1Lxbx0JQ

Is this trade fair? There is a 2008 rares list Advent on there. Thanks!

[Snorrl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867819&userid=250052&signature=muZBCazd8NIxwe1Lxbx0JQ

Is this trade fair? There is a 2008 rares list Advent on there. Thanks!

unfair to the black advent

[Nikki Amaranti]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19867819&userid=250052&signature=muZBCazd8NIxwe1Lxbx0JQ

Is this trade fair? There is a 2008 rares list Advent on there. Thanks!

Unfair to the BA.
BA is on the September List- not to mention it's worth much more due to it's demand as well.