The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Jettalli]

Not an actual trade yet as this was more asked in a PM, but how fair would it be to trade the 2011 rare pps horse for the 2010 bay horse pps? Attaching picture links because I honestly don't know the actual community given names.

Mine: http://static.chickensmoothie.com/pic.php?k=C7188DDF60DF3C2531BF53B1B042BFE3&bg=8ca4f1
Theirs: http://static.chickensmoothie.com/pic.php?k=2A7394D1FEBE68F1780254C84610D417&bg=8ca4f1

Should be fair, if I remember correctly the 2011 PPS was released in Feb and the 2010 PPS was released in November/December.

Thank you. You are right on the months they were released too.

[Shika]

Would a Bone PPS and a Pink Cookie dog be fair for a Raven dog?

unfair to cookie and bone:)

Thank you for the advice.

[Tea.Time]

is this fair?

thanks in advance =]

[Palaye Royale]

Is this fair?

[Jesavaldo]

Quick question
I have an original date target dog
Someone wants to trade me a 2010 floppy eared pink September for it
Now I know my rarities and all, but would that be a good trade??

[Fat Unicorn]

Quick question
I have an original date target dog
Someone wants to trade me a 2010 floppy eared pink September for it
Now I know my rarities and all, but would that be a good trade??

The target dog has more demand than the pink floppy. (By the way, the floppy is from 2008.)

[Jesavaldo]

Quick question
I have an original date target dog
Someone wants to trade me a 2010 floppy eared pink September for it
Now I know my rarities and all, but would that be a good trade??

The target dog has more demand than the pink floppy. (By the way, the floppy is from 2008.)

Oh yea I knew it was a 2008, but with the target dog I wasnt sure on whether demand or it's place on the list would be more important

[rabbit...]

Now would this be fair? It looks like a rerelease but thats because I think a lot of rerelease are it 11'...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wAewlJvogw
Thank You!
And talking about rereleases how do you know if it is one?

[Fat Unicorn]

Now would this be fair? It looks like a rerelease but thats because I think a lot of rerelease are it 11'...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wAewlJvogw
Thank You!
And talking about rereleases how do you know if it is one?

A rerelease will have the date 2011-12-18/2011-18-24 or 2010-12-18 or 2009-12-18/2009-12-19 or 2008-12-18.
Basically, if the pet was adopted on the 18th of December.

Your cat is a rerelease, and I'd say unfair to them.

[Pinkdragonwings]

Hi!

I was wondering which bid is better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pnmGUtgQRg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QIePPRo7Pg