The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[sabernath]

Is this fair...? And this...? If they're not, please let me know what would make them fair, too. ^^

And thanks for any help! c:

[Celozon]

o.O I cannot believe I just got randomly offered a BA. Without asking for one.
Anyway. I really want to know if this is fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LH804ERYBg

[catalie]

Hi. I'm helping my sister get her dreamie, and wanted to make sure this trade would be fair.
(We're still looking for someone who wants to trade the pet she wants, but I want to see if the trade will be fair before she sends it.)

So we're looking for a Buckskin PPS. She's wlling to offer a Blood Dog, Banana Dog (Re-Release), and a CS Birthday Koi (Another Re-Release). I'm not quite sure if it's fair, though... Any advice?

She also may be able to add on some rare/very rare rats.

Thank you for any help!

[Faybell]

Green liontail + ________ = Devil/blood PPS

I'm trying to trade down my PPS and get a minor dream or two but I have no idea what would be fair. >_<

[Umbrellas]

o.O I cannot believe I just got randomly offered a BA. Without asking for one.
Anyway. I really want to know if this is fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LH804ERYBg

I think this is fair if not slightly unfair to you...the Black Advent and the Sleipnir probably cover the orange ceb, if not slightly under for it, and the Rose Dog is slightly overpaying for the rest. But get another opinion.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

o.O I cannot believe I just got randomly offered a BA. Without asking for one.
Anyway. I really want to know if this is fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LH804ERYBg

I think this is fair if not slightly unfair to you...the Black Advent and the Sleipnir probably cover the orange ceb, if not slightly under for it, and the Rose Dog is slightly overpaying for the rest. But get another opinion.

the gap is bigger than a sleipnir [in rarity]. its about a target dog.
anyways. its unfair to them. in rarity and demand.

[KathrynKat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IhgYOKIaUg

[Celozon]

o.O I cannot believe I just got randomly offered a BA. Without asking for one.
Anyway. I really want to know if this is fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LH804ERYBg

I think this is fair if not slightly unfair to you...the Black Advent and the Sleipnir probably cover the orange ceb, if not slightly under for it, and the Rose Dog is slightly overpaying for the rest. But get another opinion.

the gap is bigger than a sleipnir [in rarity]. its about a target dog.
anyways. its unfair to them. in rarity and demand.

Thank you ^.^
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CSTEAfVdnQ
Would this edit be fair or do I need to add more?
If so, about how much?

[Captain Chomp]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EzmCyVauNA

This is about fair right? the pink cookie is four lines under and the holly cat is 6 lines below the red cerbrus so this is about slight overpay/underpay?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19410719&userid=234770&signature=BuXUl-Nz1X3hEzmCyVauNA

This is about fair right? the pink cookie is four lines under and the holly cat is 6 lines below the red cerbrus so this is about slight overpay/underpay?

about fair. maybe slight overpay on your part