The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[harpy01]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oMJ55yiX_g

fair?

[Lust]

How fair is this?
I know where each pet stands on the rarity list. Obviously the BA is not even near the Red Toxic, but I want to know if this would be fair demand wise.
I've seen Black Advents go for sorberts or higher on a couple of occasions before. Do people still value them that much?
I'd like an opinion or two of that's possible c:

[sabernath]

Is this fair...? And this...? If they're not, please let me know what would make them fair, too. ^^

And thanks for any help! c:

First one's unfair to you. the second one I don't know about. The first one, take off everything except one or two '10s or 4 '11uncommons.

Thank you. c:

I'd like some more opinions and I still need help with the second one. ^^

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19408902&userid=342689&signature=04ViHyFOqE-RoMJ55yiX_g

fair?

unfair to them

[Sonmi-451]

Is this a fair trade? If not, how can it be changed to be made fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

I think a bit unfair to you, but get another opinion.

Ok, thank you very much. May I have a second opinion?

Unfair to Winged Blood dog

Thank you very much. Does anyone have an idea as to what should be added?

[l'amour.]

How fair is this?
I know where each pet stands on the rarity list. Obviously the BA is not even near the Red Toxic, but I want to know if this would be fair demand wise.
I've seen Black Advents go for sorberts or higher on a couple of occasions before. Do people still value them that much?
I'd like an opinion or two of that's possible c:

Pretty fair to the Red Tox, but you might want another opinion.
The BA's demand has gone down a bit, but so has the Red Tox's.

[boat]

Is this trade fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -2v3gEh_Dg

If not, what should be added/removed? Thanks to anyone who helps :3

[harpy01]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4a37LAyV0A

fair?

[Faybell]

Green liontail + ________ = Devil/blood PPS

I'm trying to trade down my PPS and get a minor dream or two but I have no idea what would be fair. >_<

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

How fair is this?
I know where each pet stands on the rarity list. Obviously the BA is not even near the Red Toxic, but I want to know if this would be fair demand wise.
I've seen Black Advents go for sorberts or higher on a couple of occasions before. Do people still value them that much?
I'd like an opinion or two of that's possible c:

Pretty fair to the Red Tox, but you might want another opinion.
The BA's demand has gone down a bit, but so has the Red Tox's.

Insanely unfair to the red toxic.