The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Lufi]

Hi, is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O_CdpmIZ_g

Thankyou for any replys =D

unfair to you! and lot! - it's re-released 2008 dog
(also this dog is again rare - was VR... so is big chance that will VR again soon)

[shay ;]

Is this fair? I need serious help. I can't believe how bad at rarities I am C:

+

this!

[Nightflies]

Hi, is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O_CdpmIZ_g

Thankyou for any replys =D

unfair to you! and lot! - it's re-released 2008 dog
(also this dog is again rare - was VR... so is big chance that will VR again soon)

ok thankyou, do you know what could be added on their side to make it fair?

[Delirius]

Is this fair? I need serious help. I can't believe how bad at rarities I am C:

+

this!

1. Very close to fair, maybe swaying one way or the other, but I believe they are overpaying
2. Way unfair to you ^^

[b-star]

Is this fair? I need serious help. I can't believe how bad at rarities I am C:

+

this!

1. Very close to fair, maybe swaying one way or the other, but I believe they are overpaying
2. Way unfair to you ^^

1. I half agree with @skittles on this one. I was once told an 09 rare would equal a new set of store pets. I don't 100% trust what I had been told, but I know it's something like that, maybe just 3 new store pets equals an 09 rare (depending on the rare) They are defiantly overpaying for the store horses ^^

2. As said above ^

[Nala5]

This trade.
Help me, please? ^^;

Anyone, please?

I think the trade is unfair to you but I wouldn't go off my word.

Okay, thanks.
Second opinion, please?
And what should I remove/add to make it fair? :3

[shay ;]

Is this fair? I need serious help. I can't believe how bad at rarities I am C:

+

this!

1. Very close to fair, maybe swaying one way or the other, but I believe they are overpaying
2. Way unfair to you ^^

1. I half agree with @skittles on this one. I was once told an 09 rare would equal a new set of store pets. I don't 100% trust what I had been told, but I know it's something like that, maybe just 3 new store pets equals an 09 rare (depending on the rare) They are defiantly overpaying for the store horses ^^

2. As said above ^

So, should I accept the 1st? I cancelled the 2nd already! C: thank you for your help.

[Delirius]

This trade.
Help me, please? ^^;

I think the trade is unfair to you but I wouldn't go off my word.

Okay, thanks.
Second opinion, please?
And what should I remove/add to make it fair? :3

close, but unfair to you :)
maybe a couple more 2010 rares? or another 2009 rare?
I can tell what is fair/unfair, but I dunno what you can add x3

[b-star]

So, should I accept the 1st? I cancelled the 2nd already! C: thank you for your help.

Do whatever you want I guess ? The old ponies have really low demand. Well, at least lower demand then the butterfly wolves. The extra 2 pets help, I guess. But demand wise, unfair to you. Rarity wise maybe even a little unfair to them? But you choose, it's your trade.

[DesireeCollins]

This trade.
Help me, please? ^^;

Anyone, please?

Okay, thanks.
Second opinion, please?
And what should I remove/add to make it fair? :3

Unfair to you... Idk what the proper pet to remove would be but if it were me I would remove the pps. But it is unfair to you right now.