The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this fair

Unfair to you.

[DesireeCollins]

Is this fair

Thank you

This is unfair to you, I agree with unicorn^^

[F.Nova]

Is this fair?

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this fair?

Unfair to you ~ D:

[tigerwish~]

Okay, I've got quite a long list here x3 I would be very grateful to have some quick, and experienced answers. As I will be leaving on vacation within the next day and would like to get my auction sorted out before them. ^-^

1.Bid for Blue and Pink balloon dogs They are also offering 2 red rose dogs OR a BMD in addition to the cake set and line tribal.
Would that be a fair trade? I think, according to the rares list, they are overpaying, correct? However...
- What does the DIY cake set go for these days? Is there any demand for it?
- Line tribal is above both balloon dogs, but which has the most demand?

2.Bid for blue balloon
- (Same as above question) Is the demand of the line tribal a good investment to get higher on the rares list?
- Compared to the offer above, which would be a better deal?

3.Bid for pink and blue balloon dogs+random rares
- Would that be about fair?
- Does the UR butterbun have any demand? Again, would it be a good investment to move higher up the rares list?

Thank you so much in advance! I really appreciate it <33
~Shimmy =^.^=

[F.Nova]

Is this fair?

Unfair to you ~ D:

How can I make it fair?

[Fat Unicorn]

Okay, I've got quite a long list here x3 I would be very grateful to have some quick, and experienced answers. As I will be leaving on vacation within the next day and would like to get my auction sorted out before them. ^-^

1.Bid for Blue and Pink balloon dogs They are also offering 2 red rose dogs OR a BMD in addition to the cake set and line tribal.
Would that be a fair trade? I think, according to the rares list, they are overpaying, correct? However...
- What does the DIY cake set go for these days? Is there any demand for it?
- Line tribal is above both balloon dogs, but which has the most demand?

2.Bid for blue balloon
- (Same as above question) Is the demand of the line tribal a good investment to get higher on the rares list?
- Compared to the offer above, which would be a better deal?

3.Bid for pink and blue balloon dogs+random rares
- Would that be about fair?
- Does the UR butterbun have any demand? Again, would it be a good investment to move higher up the rares list?

Thank you so much in advance! I really appreciate it <33
~Shimmy =^.^=

1.
Technically: Yes, they are overpaying.
Demandwise: The DIY Cake Set is very hard to swap for a UR Apple, and the Line Tribal has very bad demand. The balloon dogs have more demand than the Line or DIY and I'd recommend keeping the balloon dogs. If you were to accept this bid then at least try and get the BMD or Red Rose(s) so you have some good/exceptional fodder if you need it.

2.
Technically: Unfair to them.
Demandwise: I wouldn't advise going after this one either, because of the Line Tribal. The punk dog and July lioness are a great touch, and would be helpful if you were to accept this bid.

3.
Technically: Would say it's ok, if not overpay on their behalf.
Demandwise: Honestly would not take it. Sure the UR butterbun has people on their toes and has a bit of demand, but it's a bit of a tricky bugger to trade off.

Is this fair?

Unfair to you ~ D:

How can I make it fair?

Since the gap isn't very big (2 months out of 5 month range), maybe toss in a few recent wishlist un/commons on their side?

[jormungandr]

Thanks you to the people who answered my other one, but I have a new one.
This one.

Edit-
I have a small feeling this is unfair.

[Draoslo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19392287&userid=195046&signature=NRAE91cubaW10JQIhg9Gqg

Is this fair?

Thank you!

[*autumn*]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dnklSLVyIA
Would this be fair?? I know both dogs have a fair big of demand.

Thanks if you can help