The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Also, is this fair or unfair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19341614&userid=232552&signature=TEsQ5_uX46KtaYVnlEdNlQ

Unfair to the other person. You should swap the malk dog with a 2010 uncommon then it would be fair.

the malk dog is a 2010..
if you mean he fox. its a december 2010-january 2011.
seems fair to me. maybe even unfair to the malks by demand

[Sc7856]

Also, is this fair or unfair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19341614&userid=232552&signature=TEsQ5_uX46KtaYVnlEdNlQ

Unfair to the other person. You should swap the malk dog with a 2010 uncommon then it would be fair.

the malk dog is a 2010..
if you mean he fox. its a december 2010-january 2011.
seems fair to me. maybe even unfair to the malks by demand

Woops messed up there it was meant to be a uncommon because the malk dog is common.

[brian emo]

Also, is this fair or unfair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19341614&userid=232552&signature=TEsQ5_uX46KtaYVnlEdNlQ

Unfair to the other person. You should swap the malk dog with a 2010 uncommon then it would be fair.

the malk dog is a 2010..
if you mean he fox. its a december 2010-january 2011.
seems fair to me. maybe even unfair to the malks by demand

looks fair to me too.

[lucky333123]

Is this now fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3J6CK5TD6w

[spideypuhl]

Also, is this fair or unfair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19341614&userid=232552&signature=TEsQ5_uX46KtaYVnlEdNlQ

Unfair to the other person. You should swap the malk dog with a 2010 uncommon then it would be fair.

the malk dog is a 2010..
if you mean he fox. its a december 2010-january 2011.
seems fair to me. maybe even unfair to the malks by demand

Thank you.

Fair or Unfair?
2010 June Unicorn + 2010 #2 Horse + 2010 #4 Horse + Blue Fish Rat for 2009 Nick Dog
Every pet is an uncommon except the dog.

[quitting99983]

40 item from DIY cake set = ?

Seriously Shocking Rainbow really has 40 items from the DIY cake set You should go look if you don't believe me. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/e ... ner=347223

EDIT: Sorry its actually 42

well 42 isnt a full set..
so maybe a high september or two
get another opinion

Thank you very much! Need a second opinion.

Sorry, I disagree >.<
Its fair with a high september or two, but most would never offer that.
I have most of it, and am only missing a few candles and sprinkles, but the most people offer is 1 high September without any demand.

[Dragon Attack]

Is this fair? If not what should be added/removed?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

40 item from DIY cake set = ?

Seriously Shocking Rainbow really has 40 items from the DIY cake set :) You should go look if you don't believe me. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/e ... ner=347223

EDIT: Sorry its actually 42 :P

well 42 isnt a full set..
so maybe a high september or two
get another opinion

Thank you very much! Need a second opinion.

Sorry, I disagree >.<
Its fair with a high september or two, but most would never offer that.
I have most of it, and am only missing a few candles and sprinkles, but the most people offer is 1 high September without any demand.

the full cake set is worth an apple-balloon.
1-2 high septembers would be fine for that incomplete set
doesnt matter what people will offer, thats what its worth and thats what is fair

[līga]

Would Haloween 08 VR cat + Emerald butterfly wolf (VR, April 2009) + VR July 2009 BW + July VR 2009 BW be fair fair for a angel Advent from 2008?
If not what should be removed or added?

thank you!

[Kiare]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4aj06fAmaA O.O I saw this and went Whattttt? Dang they like the lion