new thread;

[zanderism]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18710917&userid=332667&signature=2K7QhPKwh1x4CeYvujwfYQ
Is this fair, and what do I have to add to make it fair if it isn't? Thanks in advance!

you were answered on the last page..

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QIifNuTndA

very unfair to you

Sorry, didn't see it.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Does anyone know if this is fair or not? Thanks

looks unfair to them ^^

[shadows of stars]

Thanks guys. I thought so myself, but I just needed some extra feedback. Hmm, now I'm off to try to edit...

[Corn Snake <3]

Does anyone know if this is fair or not? Thanks

looks unfair to them ^^

Thanks trouble =)

[euro22]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Cm1OC3WlZA

I'm pretty sure thats way unfair to you ^^

Ok. What do I need to add. remove to make it fair?

[Member Lydia]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8RsSGXErlA unfair ? fair? thanks for any and all help c:

[33Kitty]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18710917&userid=332667&signature=2K7QhPKwh1x4CeYvujwfYQ
Is this fair, and how much do I have to add to make it fair if it isn't? Thanks in advance!

While I'm not the best judge, seeing as I haven't done any trading at all the past eight months, and haven't accepted anything in slightly over that, (meaning that I'm pretty much clueless when it comes to 2012 pets) it doesn't look like you have gotten any other responses so I feel bad not chiming in.^^

I would say that the trade is slanted slightly in favor of the top user with the single VR and no others, without any emotional/personal attachments the traders may have.
However...
If the bottom (hehe, uke) really wants said VR, and doesn't really value the rares they are offering, then it is almost reasonable, but still slanted against them.
If the bottom is offering so many rares only because the top won't accept otherwise, I would consider it slanted strongly against the bottom and certainly unfair.

Seeing as the VR dog is a late 2011, I wouldn't count it equal with even the 2009 VR butterfly wolf and maybe a two or three of the rares, unless it is very near OMG and the butterfly nearer a regular rare status. Then, I'd offer the butterfly wolf and several of the older rares; not the 2008 one, but more around the 2009-mid 2010 range. If the top wouldn't accept that, I wouldn't bother, but then again, I've always been a bit harsh... xD

what you wrote was a bit confusing.. and has some wrong information.
for one their dog is a high advent [08 advent rerelease]. the butter is worth a low advent. there is a lot more to just dates when involving the advent and rares lists.
the other pets dont seem to fill the gap.
looks unfair to them. possibly fair.

Knowing that, I agree with what you say. This is where going on trade-hiatus makes me ignorant... I can't tell what's an re-release/advent/etc and what's just a regular monthly pet...
*runs off to refresh memory*
Listen to this person over me, she/he is smarter. ^^
((As for my being confusing, well, I'm merely a confusing person. :3))

[Darkness...]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19214497&userid=290290&signature=tzneCrNckfVpMU2BQuO56A

This person is being really nice, I understand an over pay is expected but I'm not sure...advice?

Help? :3

[shadows of stars]

Okay, so I edited the trade to this:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3Ob9IjYnkA

Is this fair? I already sent it; just want some opinions on it now.

[12wolfie]

Okay, so I edited the trade to this:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3Ob9IjYnkA

Is this fair? I already sent it; just want some opinions on it now.

Unfair to you if you go by the 3 moth rule. ^^