The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Celozon]

Is this fair?
Edit: Also this?

It's hard to tell with unknowns but because those are store pets, they are likely end up Very rare, so I'd say probably not.

Store pets are generally worth a 2009 rare each by the end of the month. But right now demand is way higher becuase they just came out. Techniacally they are fair, but if no one wants to trade than just wait till later int he month rather than adding more to your side. After demand goes down int he middle of the month they may go for 2010 rares, but by the end of the month its usually 2009 rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213972&userid=299736&signature=YaVe18SY0IeUGnOLDq4WDA
Is this fair and what would be need to be added/removed to make it fair?

Very unfair to you. The uncommon dragons are worth about a 2009 rare due to popularity, Just the purple re-release would be fair.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213430&userid=37133&signature=kcZs7NQ9MV3pOGdFFNaxxQ

Is that trade unfair? The person I was trying to trade with kept saying 'this trade is very unfair' and 'this is the most unfair trade I've ever seen' no matter how many pets I added, so is it really unfair? (Because if it is I really need help...)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213248&userid=37133&signature=PluZPVeScVItkhCKoh_CIQ
and that one... I need to know if it's unfair too... I think it was but I'm not sure...

For #1 I'd say its close to fair, but you may want another opinion. #2, unfair to them.

Are these trades fair?:

Number 1 {They're giving me the cat, wanting the dog}
Number 2 {They're giving me the horse and rabbit, wanting the items}
Number 3 {They're giving me the rat, butterfly wolf, and horse wanting the 2nd gen dog and and wingless butterfly wolf}
Number 4 {They're giving me the butterfly wolf, cat, rat, and bunny wanting the two items}

#1. A bit unfair to them.
#2. Fair.
#3. A little unfair to them.
#4. I don't know how much the items are worth exactly, but since they were free I'd say fair or close to fair.

[Celozon]

Is this fair? (There is 100CS added to the red toxic side)
And you can pretty much ignore the items sice they don't mean much next to the spotted tribal.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LfDYsbvLng


And is this fair? What should be added/taken out if unfair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CydD2O1wtg

[Physical-Pancakes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213430&userid=37133&signature=kcZs7NQ9MV3pOGdFFNaxxQ

Is that trade unfair? The person I was trying to trade with kept saying 'this trade is very unfair' and 'this is the most unfair trade I've ever seen' no matter how many pets I added, so is it really unfair? (Because if it is I really need help...)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213248&userid=37133&signature=PluZPVeScVItkhCKoh_CIQ
and that one... I need to know if it's unfair too... I think it was but I'm not sure...

For #1 I'd say its close to fair, but you may want another opinion. #2, unfair to them.

K thanks, why is #2 unfair to them? These are all wishlist pets, I know you're probably right... I just want to know...

[Snorrl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17214148&userid=299736&signature=aMZEq_BYjOse6YgXfKo2_g
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17214123&userid=299736&signature=ugHMURx34B1uGLriFxWSjQ
are these fair? thanks in advance!

[Obius]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ld_XW6niRg Any help with this one would be great! ^^

Wassap

[Snorrl]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17214126&userid=230834&signature=DSQ-dLdUa8-hLd_XW6niRg Any help with this one would be great! ^^

Wassap

unfair to them by the 3-month rule, although it might be fair by demand

[Obius]

I figured the Staff Litters are in demand at least to some extent. So thats what I was considering. Anyone else know if thats fair?

[Celozon]

I figured the Staff Litters are in demand at least to some extent. So thats what I was considering. Anyone else know if thats fair?

I agree with Somnivis. Technically unfair to them, but its fair in demand.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213430&userid=37133&signature=kcZs7NQ9MV3pOGdFFNaxxQ

Is that trade unfair? The person I was trying to trade with kept saying 'this trade is very unfair' and 'this is the most unfair trade I've ever seen' no matter how many pets I added, so is it really unfair? (Because if it is I really need help...)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=17213248&userid=37133&signature=PluZPVeScVItkhCKoh_CIQ
and that one... I need to know if it's unfair too... I think it was but I'm not sure...

For #1 I'd say its close to fair, but you may want another opinion. #2, unfair to them.

K thanks, why is #2 unfair to them? These are all wishlist pets, I know you're probably right... I just want to know...

Thants alright ^.^

Its unfair becuase rats tend to be worth less than cats and dogs, plus 2010 pets are worth a lot more than 2012 and 2011. Taking into considerationt hat the 2011 pets are from late 2011 and 2012 pets are all fairly recent, they are not worth a early 2010 dog and a cat that is at least midly popular.

[beanbag1234]

How in demand is the 09 UR Dog? What do they usually go for? thanks in advance

[leaf]

oops posted on good trade thread on accident--

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YVNgNxdnaQ

i tried to use the Xat chat but it wouldnt connect for me

they sent this to me and i was obviously wondering if it was fair.. i'm horrible with older pets/large amounts

thanks in advance c: