The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[SSQM]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NGS6LTGTdQ

Is this fair? if it's not, who is it unfair to and how can we fix it? :3

[burnside]

Is this fair to top?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bHctkoh1fQ
Is the bottom overpaying??

Unfair to top
Butter dogs (I know from experience) go for '09 Rares as do Store wigs

Please don't give false advice :3
Just because people are willing to overpay for the Butterdog with '09 Rares, doesn't mean that's what it's worth ^^
It's true worth won't be known until the rarity comes out but I've heard from more rarity-wise people that it will be worth a handful of '11 Uncommons at most. Don't take my word for that though because I'm not sure ^^
As for this trade, I'm not sure what the wig is worth so I honestly can't say if this is fair or not c;

It's not exactullaly false advise, it's rarity is unknown but demand worth only about ten in one hundred people got them so it makes them pretty rare as many people want them. I traded 2 for '09 Rares each, and no that dosent make them worth Rares alone, its the demand same with Shima Longtails they are uncommons but go for multiple Rares.
So demand wise there're worth Rares, Rarity wise ATM there're worth a couple of uncommons

[lunar-lynx]

Please don't give false advice :3
Just because people are willing to overpay for the Butterdog with '09 Rares, doesn't mean that's what it's worth ^^
It's true worth won't be known until the rarity comes out but I've heard from more rarity-wise people that it will be worth a handful of '11 Uncommons at most. Don't take my word for that though because I'm not sure ^^
As for this trade, I'm not sure what the wig is worth so I honestly can't say if this is fair or not c;

It's not exactullaly false advise, it's rarity is unknown but demand worth only about ten in one hundred people got them so it makes them pretty rare as many people want them. I traded 2 for '09 Rares each, and no that dosent make them worth Rares alone, its the demand same with Shima Longtails they are uncommons but go for multiple Rares.
So demand wise there're worth Rares, Rarity wise ATM there're worth a couple of uncommons

Like I said before, just because people are willing to overpay for the Butterdog with '09 Rares, doesn't mean that's what it's worth(:
Don't believe me? Ask DaDwarf or Hekomi or someone that knows what they're talking about. That's where I got this advice from and they're the most rarity wise users I know.

EDIT: Also, if you have anything else to say, please PM me. I'm not about to get into trouble for spamming the thread with this senseless argument. Thank you.

[lkjhgfdsamnbvcxz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16562070&userid=79281&signature=8AoslxmS83ZUNGS6LTGTdQ

Is this fair? if it's not, who is it unfair to and how can we fix it? :3

the mustache + maracas would be worth around a late '10 UC, the muffin = late '10 UC as well, the bow = a '10 common, and the red eggs = early '10 UC each, so quite unfair to you. ^^

[Fat Unicorn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16562070&userid=79281&signature=8AoslxmS83ZUNGS6LTGTdQ

Is this fair? if it's not, who is it unfair to and how can we fix it? :3

Unfair to you, I'd say.
Those items definitely aren't recent. Those pets don't cut it right, either. Unfortunately I don't know how to fix it.
/not great with items

[burnside]

Please don't give false advice :3
Just because people are willing to overpay for the Butterdog with '09 Rares, doesn't mean that's what it's worth ^^
It's true worth won't be known until the rarity comes out but I've heard from more rarity-wise people that it will be worth a handful of '11 Uncommons at most. Don't take my word for that though because I'm not sure ^^
As for this trade, I'm not sure what the wig is worth so I honestly can't say if this is fair or not c;

It's not exactullaly false advise, it's rarity is unknown but demand worth only about ten in one hundred people got them so it makes them pretty rare as many people want them. I traded 2 for '09 Rares each, and no that dosent make them worth Rares alone, its the demand same with Shima Longtails they are uncommons but go for multiple Rares.
So demand wise there're worth Rares, Rarity wise ATM there're worth a couple of uncommons

Like I said before, just because people are willing to overpay for the Butterdog with '09 Rares, doesn't mean that's what it's worth(:
Don't believe me? Ask DaDwarf or Hekomi. That's where I got this advice from and they're the most rarity wise users I know.

I'm not saying that its worth a rare, I'm saying Demand wise (wich is not say what it is actually worth) a LOT of people want one making it harder to find one for trade making it Rarer. As with the Longtail.
Even quoting you 'Based on demand it's unfair to you' the ButterDog is in demand ATM.
And yes I do believe you. He's probily worth a couple of uncommons as you said.
I'm going to bed now, so good night and if that still makes me giving out 'false information' I'm truly sorry.

-Shur

[Fat Unicorn]

@ Shur'Tugal and WolvesGoRawr,
The UR butterdog is probably worth about a handful of late 11
un/commons or a handful of early 12 un/commons. People are simply overreacting about how rare this pet really is - it's just like the new URs. There is no set value for it yet. Simple. Saying to someone to pay 2009 rares for a recent outcome is like saying to someone to pay a Sunback for a low Advent.

And you can't just ask Hekomi and DaDwarf about rarities, you can even ask the people in the first post under the main post about it. They'll tell you.
Now please take your argument to PM and stop spamming.

[sturmi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IC23s-NuKQ
Is this fair? If not what should they add?
Thanks for any help!

[DaDwarf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16553746&userid=267823&signature=0DHu_AwyELLBIC23s-NuKQ
Is this fair? If not what should they add?
Thanks for any help!

Unfair to you, they need to add at least an early 09 rare or two. Possible more.

[sturmi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16553746&userid=267823&signature=0DHu_AwyELLBIC23s-NuKQ
Is this fair? If not what should they add?
Thanks for any help!

Unfair to you, they need to add at least an early 09 rare or two. Possible more.

Thank you!