The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Shian]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=16406718&userid=254872&signature=tKCxt2_MkDvzTI0n2agvmg
Thank you guys for you help- again xD

Unfair to Bone PPS.

Okay, say I add another '09 rare cat and a couple '09 rare pets to their side. Would it be O.K. then?

Rarity math does not help you. It depends entirely on what pet "an 09 rare" is. Which cat?

[folle]

Specifically, a Christmas '09 cat, that rare '09 orange Malk wolf, an '09 PPS orange and blue dog, and a 2011 brown stripey PPS that I think is a re-release but I'm not sure what its real year is.

[Shian]

Would this be a fair offer for the Evil PPS?
It's my dreamie so I want to overpay but I don't want to overpay too much.

Looks like a good start to me. You may end up having to add a few more pets like many of this year's uncommons if they have any of those on their wishlist. It's best to tailor to what the the trader might be interested in. If you're looking for 'not overpay' then figure out what the trader likes. If they don't like horses for example then taking out those horses won't make much of a difference to them so you can end up keeping them and adding in one or two dogs instead. If you're trading to a rat lover, I'd say that trade might not even be remotely interesting.

[Klea]

Would this be a fair offer for the Evil PPS?
It's my dreamie so I want to overpay but I don't want to overpay too much.

Looks like a good start to me. You may end up having to add a few more pets like many of this year's uncommons if they have any of those on their wishlist. It's best to tailor to what the the trader might be interested in. If you're looking for 'not overpay' then figure out what the trader likes. If they don't like horses for example then taking out those horses won't make much of a difference to them so you can end up keeping them and adding in one or two dogs instead. If you're trading to a rat lover, I'd say that trade might not even be remotely interesting.

Agreed

[folle]

Specifically, a Christmas '09 cat, that rare '09 orange Malk wolf, an '09 PPS orange and blue dog, and a 2011 brown stripey PPS that I think is a re-release but I'm not sure what its real year is.

Okay, the re-release is an '08 October rare.

[Shian]

Specifically, a Christmas '09 cat, that rare '09 orange Malk wolf, an '09 PPS orange and blue dog, and a 2011 brown stripey PPS that I think is a re-release but I'm not sure what its real year is.

I have no idea what 'an orange and blue dog' is, there are 3 09 malk orange wolves- one way more rare than the other two and the brown stripe PPS puppy could be an Oct 08, in which case you'd have to end up taking some off from your side.

[Kaga87]

Hi there, would be happy if you could help me with this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WJhGXsbpHA

Thank you very much ^.^

[folle]

Okay, so this trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TI0n2agvmg
Plus an '08 October PPS, a '09 Malk Wolf, and an '09 PPS rare blue and orange pup on their side. Is that okay?

[Shian]

Hi there, would be happy if you could help me with this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WJhGXsbpHA

Thank you very much ^.^

Not at all fair to you. Token pets took a bit of work to get.

[ChocolateFate]

Would this be a fair offer for the Evil PPS?
It's my dreamie so I want to overpay but I don't want to overpay too much.

Looks like a good start to me. You may end up having to add a few more pets like many of this year's uncommons if they have any of those on their wishlist. It's best to tailor to what the the trader might be interested in. If you're looking for 'not overpay' then figure out what the trader likes. If they don't like horses for example then taking out those horses won't make much of a difference to them so you can end up keeping them and adding in one or two dogs instead. If you're trading to a rat lover, I'd say that trade might not even be remotely interesting.

Thank you so mcuh -Firestar-!