The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[hyaci]

Is this fair? And if it's not than who needs to add what?

Thank you!

[Amethysts]

A user cancelled this saying they would never do this trade, but I thought it was overpay. What should I have added, or were those pets just special to them?

It was actually unfair to them.
The peaPPS goes for a late '09 rare.
And the old store horses are in demand still..

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 80Nr3_rqCQ
Need some help. Thanks.

[Alice Cullen.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15751969&userid=227554&signature=U3wkuitx3ERezZPd9ZVvfA

Fair? I'm not quite sure...

[TwilightStallion]

A user cancelled this saying they would never do this trade, but I thought it was overpay. What should I have added, or were those pets just special to them?

It was actually unfair to them.
The peaPPS goes for a late '09 rare.
And the old store horses are in demand still..

But for every rare I asked for( bar 1), I gave '09 Rares for... Surely the fact that I gave a'10 rare for an '11 should cancel something out? And I thought the old store dogs are worth '10 Rares each, as well?

[Amethysts]

A user cancelled this saying they would never do this trade, but I thought it was overpay. What should I have added, or were those pets just special to them?

It was actually unfair to them.
The peaPPS goes for a late '09 rare.
And the old store horses are in demand still..

But for every rare I asked for( bar 1), I gave '09 Rares for... Surely the fact that I gave a'10 rare for an '11 should cancel something out? And I thought the old store dogs are worth '10 Rares each, as well?

You have that right, but not a lot of people like rats.
The whole trade was actually on the PeaPPS & The two store horses.
Not a lot of people like to trade them for rares/VRs that aren't demand-wise.

[TwilightStallion]

It was actually unfair to them.
The peaPPS goes for a late '09 rare.
And the old store horses are in demand still..

But for every rare I asked for( bar 1), I gave '09 Rares for... Surely the fact that I gave a'10 rare for an '11 should cancel something out? And I thought the old store dogs are worth '10 Rares each, as well?

You have that right, but not a lot of people like rats.
The whole trade was actually on the PeaPPS & The two store horses.
Not a lot of people like to trade them for rares/VRs that aren't demand-wise.

Oh, ok. Thank-you!

[Amethysts]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 80Nr3_rqCQ

Doubt anyone was gonna see this^^
Comments? Thanks~
What should be added? c;

[♥Sterek♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15752078&userid=284780&signature=0g7A_Q9mFwL780Nr3_rqCQ

Doubt anyone was gonna see this^^
Comments? Thanks~
What should be added? c;

Unfair to u.. the tess horses have very bad demand.. since the collies are quite wanted..

[voidsounds]

Was this a fair trade?

[Amethysts]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15752078&userid=284780&signature=0g7A_Q9mFwL780Nr3_rqCQ

Doubt anyone was gonna see this^^
Comments? Thanks~
What should be added? c;

Unfair to u.. the tess horses have very bad demand.. since the collies are quite wanted..

Thanks.

Second opinion? I need to know what needs to be added.

Was this a fair trade?

No, it was unfair to you.