The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[BookAuthor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uh_WiX-Uvw is this fair?

[Caskett]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IRc-a1S0OQ

[Dennie]

Is this fair? Thanks =)

fair, if you want those pets :3 probably not desirable if you don't want them

please dont give false advice. its unfair to the 2010 dog

I respectfully disagree

[Panne]

BE galaxy+CE Galaxy+Red toxic fair for nonswirl?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

BE galaxy+CE Galaxy+Red toxic fair for nonswirl?

seems fair to me

[ToTo :D]

Is this fair? Thanks =)

fair, if you want those pets :3 probably not desirable if you don't want them

please dont give false advice. its unfair to the 2010 dog

It's unfair to the '10 dog, dates matter more than quantity

[Diddlebug]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IRc-a1S0OQ

Unfair to you, you could so much more for that 08 dog

[james moriarty]

BE galaxy+CE Galaxy+Red toxic fair for nonswirl?

seems fair to me

I just asked the same thing, Trouble, and you said it was unfair to them...?

[Dennie]

Is this fair? Thanks =)

fair, if you want those pets :3 probably not desirable if you don't want them

It's unfair to the '10 dog, dates matter more than quantity

if it were a rare, I would agree with you. as it is not, 4 uncommons from the following year is plenty fair for 1 uncommon, particularly since they are event pets

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

BE galaxy+CE Galaxy+Red toxic fair for nonswirl?

seems fair to me

I just asked the same thing, Trouble, and you said it was unfair to them...?

unless I looked at the wrong trade and replied to yours?
can you quote me on it so I can see? I could have made a mistake, ya never know xD

Is this fair? Thanks =)

fair, if you want those pets :3 probably not desirable if you don't want them

It's unfair to the '10 dog, dates matter more than quantity

if it were I a rare, I would agree with you. as it is not, 4 uncommons from the following year is plenty fair for 1 uncommon, particularly since they are event pets

Please dont argue. dates, demand species etc etc have a part in this.
bunnies have less demand than dogs. and 4 bunnies that arent in demand and are incredibly easy to find. those particular bunnies werent events they were free adopts that everyone got if I'm not mistaken. that dog could fetch a lot more than that.