The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Mara.]

the rainbow mane needs more on its side

Ok, any idea on what pets could be added? ^^

[Crippling Rogue]

Bookmarking. ^^

[XanthussMarduk]

the rainbow mane needs more on its side

Ok, any idea on what pets could be added? ^^

maybe 2 or 3 09 advents

[SagittariusII]

Is this fair?
Them: all-white guinea pig
Me: 2 middle-stage shima kittenthings

[JadeiteWren]

Woot new topic XP
No trades <3 Though with the all the rarities changing lately some of my old trades have been turning in my favor or not in my favor

[Memories]

Very rare moonswirl rabbit for blue rose dog?

[nightbeat]

Is this fair?

[Crippling Rogue]

Very rare moonswirl rabbit for blue rose dog?

I don't think a VR Rabbit would really equal the demand for a Blue Rose. But that's me. I'd not want a Bunny for good trading material like the Blue Rose. D:

[Jeweled]

Is this fair?

They need more on their side. ^^

@Starstreak: Unfair for the rose dog. C:

[Santa Sue]

I joined way back in October of '08 and got a few pets then, but was having problems with my internet and strayed away, I have finally found my way back and now I have a Skeleton dog from Halloween '08 and I've got someone wanting to trade for it, I really have no idea what is fair or not, so here is a list of everything being offered so far, it's a very long list, but mostly newer or common items, so not sure what to do...

Nick's pets...
uncommon from 4/09, it's green/black, has like a skull on the butt

Malk's pets...
very common rainbow fish from 01/10
very common owl from 01/10
very common fox/pink swirls from 01/10
common green spider from 11/09
common playful looking dog from 10/09
common white owl from 10/09
common cat in bandages from 10/09
uncommon spider with eye design from 10/09
uncommon fish with swirly design from 09/09
uncommon blue and green spider from 8/09
uncommon green owl from 6/09

2nd generation...
very common green with purple swirls from 11/08
common dark purple with light purple circles from 12/08
common peachy with purplish swirlies from 01/10

2010...
common rabbit from v-day, one that I don't have
very common butterfly wolf with like pixie wings and has like a black base with white upper and purple blotches on the back
very common ricorn birthday purple dog from jan.
common horse with lightning from jan.
common horse with cloud design from jan.


christmas/dec 09...
uncommon elf looking rabbit
uncommon green dog with lights
uncommon queen of hearts
uncommon lion looking dog
uncommon lion looking dog with flowers on head
uncommon comet, cupid, vixen, dasher
uncommon dragon looking thing with candy cane on but
uncommon king of hearts
uncommon snowman cat w/hat
common grey dog with like leg stripes and circle design on back

November 09...
common purple rat with sewing needle
uncommon dog with like dragon wings, redish colors
uncommon dog that's got a spiffy looking tail and like a mane
common horse with pink stripes
common phantom of the opera rat
common rat with mime face on it

October 09...
common dog with glowing eyes, dark grey base and glowing white design
common tan dog with purple on the ears, tail tip, leg and collar
common dog that looks like it's back is sparkly pink
common rat with green and purple swirly design
common horse with blue base and splatters of purple, green and dark blue, white face and on the legs with purple mane and tail
common grey dog with white musical notes

August 09...
uncommon rainbow colored horse

May 09...
uncommon birthday pet, can't really read the writing but it's black with like firish design on bottom

april 09...
rare purple rabbit

March 09...
uncommon pale pink butterfly wolf

Help would be greatly appreciated, I really have no idea what I should be asking for it!