Would a winged blood dog from Halloween '09:

be worth the Green-fronted Holly dog AND the sockdog (both '08 advents)?
I've seen the winged blood dog on the Septembers list being worth as much as the pink striped and pink patchy September dogs.
In the "Is this a fair trade" thread I've seen people say that the scarf PPS (one space below the winged blood dog) would be worth around 2-3 mid-ranged advents, so does this mean the blood dog would rather be worth a bit less than the Green-fronted Holly dog and sockdog?
I kinda hope I'll get some help here, since my posts were somehow ignored over on the "Is this a fair trade" thread.
Thanks in advance ^^