The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Toru & Tiku]

I need quick answer :

Sunback

For

Wooden angel , joker , kiss pps , blue grinner and one Dec 2008 rare blue pps

Fair or unfair ? If unfair to which side ?

[Atwood]

It looks like too much on the Wood Angel side since the Sunback is apparently the most common Sundog and all of the dogs on the other person's side are Rare or Very Rare and highly sought, but I'm not sure on that.

[Sylvia]

I need quick answer :

Sunback

For

Wooden angel , joker , kiss pps , blue grinner and one Dec 2008 rare blue pps

Fair or unfair ? If unfair to which side ?

I would say unfair to the sunback side but I'm not completely sure what the wood angel is worth

[Paper Moon]

Blue balloon dog [VR]

for

a green butterbun [VR], a red butterbun [VR], and the rare yellow malk spider.

Fair or unfair? If unfair, which side is it unfair to?

[JadeiteWren]

Blue balloon dog [VR]

for

a green butterbun [VR], a red butterbun [VR], and the rare yellow malk spider.

Fair or unfair? If unfair, which side is it unfair to?

I'd say unfair to Blue Balloon since it's older and more sought after. Spiders and Bunnies aren't very popular...

[Sylvia]

Blue balloon dog [VR]

for

a green butterbun [VR], a red butterbun [VR], and the rare yellow malk spider.

Fair or unfair? If unfair, which side is it unfair to?

I'd say unfair to Blue Balloon since it's older and more sought after. Spiders and Bunnies aren't very popular...

I agree with that...
i would say if the bunny side adds 1 or 2 more rare pets it's fine

[Paper Moon]

Blue balloon dog [VR]

for

a green butterbun [VR], a red butterbun [VR], and the rare yellow malk spider.

Fair or unfair? If unfair, which side is it unfair to?

I'd say unfair to Blue Balloon since it's older and more sought after. Spiders and Bunnies aren't very popular...

I agree with that...
i would say if the bunny side adds 1 or 2 more rare pets it's fine

Mm, thank you both. :3

[Diabolic]

Me: Nontag Moon.

Them: Floppy eared tribal.


Unfair for me? Should they add something, or, well, what value should they add?

[JadeiteWren]

Me: Nontag Moon.

Them: Floppy eared tribal.


Unfair for me? Should they add something, or, well, what value should they add?

I'd say unfair to you but I'm not 100% sure. I'd wait for another opinion.

[butcherbaby]

ok, i edited the other trade to this since they really want the dog.



is this fair? could i add the sept blue rose without being greedy? should i add or subtract pets from either side? i'm trying to get as many of my Wish pest in as a can here X-D

thank you!