The Good Trade Thread

[Khemo]

Eee. C:

I got this: (Rare) for an extra I had of this: (Common).

The other person was aware of the rarities, and wanted the common anyway. The best part is I offered a suggestion asking if I had anything they would be willing to trade, and that was what they picked. Needless to say I am very happy, I thought I wouldn't be able to get that butterwolf at first.

[letgotonight]

Mah apple. For FREE!

[falconz]

OMYGAWD
I just got a zebra for an April dog that is barely uncommon. *faintdierevive*

I feel bad for the other person

Isn't that scamming them?

[riley.∞]

I got two wishlist pets today.
First trade:
They initiated the trade;
They wanted:
They offered:
I was like... wow.

Second trade:
After a lot of editing;
They wanted: Grown Mime PPS
They offered:
I OMGed at that.
Thanks to those people!

[Madame Butterfly]

OMYGAWD
I just got a zebra for an April dog that is barely uncommon. *faintdierevive*

I feel bad for the other person

Isn't that scamming them?

Don't attack Lynx unless you know for sure if the other person had no idea. I look at a lot of trades listed here, and I see dogs given for free and etc. It seems strange to me that you attack Lynx in particular. All of these could be scams

[Sebeon]

Don't attack Lynx unless you know for sure if the other person had no idea. I look at a lot of trades listed here, and I see dogs given for free and etc. It seems strange to me that you attack Lynx in particular. All of these could be scams

That's true.
I don't get any good trades, I hope I will eventually~

If there were any good trades, then the "good" was on the other person's side, since I had a Black Advent spare, and I traded it away for nothing. xD Of course, I had no idea on how Rare it was.

Lynx never specified whether the person edited back like that on purpose or etc.

[Mara.]

The best trades I ever got were from when I was a newbie. Most of them were sent by the other person.
First trade I ever got-
Them: Uncommon rat
Me: common horse

Second trade I ever got-
Them: Uncommon dog
Me: 2 commons and 1 very common dog

Third trade I ever got
Them: Uncommon rat
Me: 2 common dogs

Another trade I got when I was a newbie
Them: Uncommon dog, common dog, common beta fish
Me: Common spider

Another trade I got from someone
Them: uncommon owl (Wishlist)
Me: nothing

[Carm]

I traded my UR butterfly wolf to a friend to contributed greatly to my pet collection (She gave me a dogtag moon + other Julys for '09 pets). She gave me a lot of bobtails for another friend's hoard and a rare rat. <3
It feels good to make people happy, lol.

[Seasonal]

I'm going to defend Lynx.

Getting a zebra for an uncommon dog is not scamming. If she said "The zebra is worth this", then it is scamming. If she didn't say that, and the person freely chose to trade their zebra, it was their choice, therefore she didn't scam them.

It's just a form of ninja-trading. If that's what the person wanted for the zebra, and they're both happy, why do values matter? Sure, it wasn't all that fair, but if they're both happy, I see nothing wrong with it.

That's kind of how I got one of my favorite dogs, the black June '08. I asked what they wanted, and they said they wanted 2nd-gens. It's what they wanted, and it's what I wanted, so I don't find anything wrong with that.

I'm not trying to be rude in any way, just stating my opinion.

[riley.∞]

@Seasonal <3: What is ninja-trading? I've heard it mentioned a lot, and I have no idea what it is...