New Thread please lock <3

[peachie.]

What about this?

(Myself I truly think they are asking a little too much)

[XCRunner]

Is this fair? Thanks! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g_ODv1L28w

[Thuban]

I dont bid very often in auctions for a few reasons: mainly people ask way too much for what they are trading off, and because I really dont have the pets that add up to what the offers are. I decided to bite the bullet and try for one, and am curious how my offer stacks up in general (for future reference of course)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YOe1HmlQWg


The person hosting the auction knows i have other things to add, but as a first bid, how far am I from what thats worth? I dont engage in trades involving those, for obvious reasons

Thats very unfair to BE Galaxy.

I agree, it's unfair to BE

I know its unfair, I knew that way before I attempted to offer. I have other stuff to add, but you guys seem to have missed the point of the question: How does the offer stack up? What in general needs to be added? (Dont say 08s, because if i had them they would have been offered ) Something that bothers me when it comes to threads like this: people are always willing to say fair or unfair, but theres hardly ever anyone to say things like "well seeing as this is what you had to work with, you would need to offer at least 50 09 rares to even get close. I know the older pets are tricky, its why I dont offer in the auctions, and I try to avoid trades involving them. Is there even a "mentoring" thread hiding on this forum?

Thanks anyhow. I realize that I will probably never understand the rarities enough to be able to offer advice on older pets. I also realize that its pointless to try to offer for older pets since I dont understand their worth.

[peachie.]

Is this fair? Thanks! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g_ODv1L28w

Very unfair to them

[Tanybrid]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tuTML0SyiA

and what about this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DtxYaFkxxg

thanks for the first! but what about the trade above??

[XCRunner]

Is this fair? Thanks! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g_ODv1L28w

Very unfair to them

Thanks!

[yumekari]

What should be removed to make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 995_Zlzubg

[Pideaux]

Thats very unfair to BE Galaxy.

I agree, it's unfair to BE

I know its unfair, I knew that way before I attempted to offer. I have other stuff to add, but you guys seem to have missed the point of the question: How does the offer stack up? What in general needs to be added? (Dont say 08s, because if i had them they would have been offered ) Something that bothers me when it comes to threads like this: people are always willing to say fair or unfair, but theres hardly ever anyone to say things like "well seeing as this is what you had to work with, you would need to offer at least 50 09 rares to even get close. I know the older pets are tricky, its why I dont offer in the auctions, and I try to avoid trades involving them. Is there even a "mentoring" thread hiding on this forum?

Thanks anyhow. I realize that I will probably never understand the rarities enough to be able to offer advice on older pets. I also realize that its pointless to try to offer for older pets since I dont understand their worth.

perhaps asking 'what do i need to add' would be the best way to phrase this instead of assuming that people understand what you mean by 'how does this offer stack up' - because honestly - if i saw that i would have told you that it didn't stack at all, was extremely unfair to the black eyed.

now. it seems as if you want to know what you would need to add to make it fair - honestly, probably around a purple toxic plus some. the offer barely scrapes up to a advent.

[CalicoWolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10668500&userid=6076&signature=Ye3ZmBtF1o3dAcuAv2LuGQ

would just the two advents be fair/overpay?

Overpay. The balloon bunny aint worth that much .

There are two bunnies there.
so would the 2 advents alone be overpay already?

[Tanybrid]

and what about this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DtxYaFkxxg