AmandaLeann wrote:DaDwarf wrote:I think you shoud remove everything but two dogs. Since they are going to give you a very rare 2008 two rares 2008 should be equal to that.I think that the way it is now you are deffently overpaying by a lot.
Please don't give out uneducated advice
. The Scarf pps is on the rares list, neither are the other dogs. The reason you state why the trade is unfair is wrong.
Julie: I am not quite sure, but it looks fair to me. Neither of those dogs are on the rares list, but with all the store items, i'd say you make a good shot. The scarf pps is on the septembers list, so i think it might even be unfair to them, still. Again, not 100% sure, so ask someone else to be sure ^.^
I was just stating my opinion. Does not mean she has to listen to me. I did say I think not this is how it is. I can say what I think even if it may seem wrong to others.
Please read the rules of this thread.
Hekomi & Jeweled wrote:If you are unsure of rarities, don't post. It's taken me months to get where I am. Rarities are not a simple math equation. It doesn't work like that. This thread has been getting more and more people who don't know about rarities posting in it like they do. Have enough respect for the people posting to not post and lead them astray if you DO NOT KNOW. If others who are knowledgeable in rarities have told you you need to learn them better, do that. It is not fair to give other people bad advice just because you think you know. It creates an even tougher job for the people who do know their rarities because they are constantly backtracking and fixing mistakes.
People are basing important trading decisions on your advice. People have been ripped off and led astray by others giving bad advice. It's giving people who do know their rarities more work because we have to back track and fix mistakes. Very rares do not equal two rares. Rarities don't work like that.
Please note that this is not directed at any particular person but a collective group of people who are posting bad advice. More and more people are getting ripped off and it's not fair.
Stating your opinion and thus giving out wrong advice is not fair towards the other person
. They might cancel a really good trade because you stated your opinion. (I don't mean to sound rude, but just..if you are not sure, don't post. You wouldn't like it if someone gave you wrong advice, then why do it to others.) If you want to turn this into a discussion, PM me, and don't post here. That's considered spam.
Too add to your just edited bit: "If you do look at the rare list it does state "While we try to keep it as up-to-date and accurate as possible, it is by no means the absolute authority on pet value."
The rares list is well up to date, and it's accurate as possible at this moment. I'm very involved in this game, i know my rarities and i know how to use the rares list. I'm a quite active reader, and follow every discussion and pet movement. Also, i'm moderator on the what is this pet worth thread, i think i can conclude when something involving the rares list is fair or not, don't you think?
Again, if you have more to say, PM me.
Honeywhisker wrote:I have two more trades I need checked over.
This one And
This one
The one with the dragon dogs if unfair to you. Dogs are worth more then horses.
As for the other trade... it seems fair, but honestly..i've seen the cat go for a little more then that, it's quite wanted since it looks like the UR cat xD.
