The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[adakie]

okay, further complication --'''' now I don't know what to accept, the first person's offer or this new person's

their offer - december snowflake pps AND december flopeared white and pale blue dog with the little leafish thing on its hip

they asked for - cerberus, new advent rat, all three Halloween red dog adults, tri-tailed red and black target dog

help o_o

[Aloaei]

Mine: December 08 Rare advent collie
Theirs: Pile of dirt cactus thing. Advent 08. Big candy cane 2nd gen. Dec 09 dog. ginger bread dog.

Fair or Unfair?

[chaos.]

i am very confused!

i this a fair trade?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699035

and is this a fair trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699057


im oh so confused :3

[loyalwolf06]

i am very confused!

i this a fair trade?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699035

and is this a fair trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699057


im oh so confused :3

We can't view those because those are trades on your account. Only the parties involved can view them. Maybe you could take screen caps of them or just describe them to us.

Do you think the first unfair too? I'd kind of like to just trade dog for dog & rat for rat, but I was told some are rarer or "more valuable."

I wouldn't accept the first either, but maybe that's just me. I don't consider a dog for a rat to be fair. Though the dogs will be re-released and the rats probably won't be, so it might be a good trade. The second one is definitely unfair to you though.

[chaos.]

i am very confused!

i this a fair trade?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699035

and is this a fair trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699057


im oh so confused :3

We can't view those because those are trades on your account. Only the parties involved can view them. Maybe you could take screen caps of them or just describe them to us.



okay, so the first:
mine: (rare)
theirs:Blue wave grown up pps, and bunny plushie



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the other one..
Mine:(very rare)
Pet's name: Rose
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
theirs:Joker dog (rare) and PPS october dog from 08 (rare)

the tribal is my fav pet.. but i dont know what to do

[chaos.]

i am very confused!

i this a fair trade?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699035

and is this a fair trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=699057


im oh so confused :3

We can't view those because those are trades on your account. Only the parties involved can view them. Maybe you could take screen caps of them or just describe them to us.

okay, so the first:
mine: (rare)
theirs:Blue wave grown up pps, and bunny plushie



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the other one..
Mine:(very rare)
Pet's name: Rose
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
theirs:Joker dog (rare) and PPS october dog from 08 (rare)

the tribal is my fav pet.. but i dont know what to do

[loyalwolf06]

We can't view those because those are trades on your account. Only the parties involved can view them. Maybe you could take screen caps of them or just describe them to us.

okay, so the first:
mine: (rare)
theirs:Blue wave grown up pps, and bunny plushie



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the other one..
Mine:(very rare)
Pet's name: Rose
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
theirs:Joker dog (rare) and PPS october dog from 08 (rare)

the tribal is my fav pet.. but i dont know what to do

The first I'd say is unfair.

The second seems like it might be fair. People will give a lot for a joker and they're offering a Joker and another dog. Though that October 08 isn't the best offer ever. If the tribal is your favorite pet and you only have the one I wouldn't accept though, just because it is your favorite and it would be very hard to get another.

[chaos.]

We can't view those because those are trades on your account. Only the parties involved can view them. Maybe you could take screen caps of them or just describe them to us.

okay, so the first:
mine: (rare)
theirs:Blue wave grown up pps, and bunny plushie



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the other one..
Mine:(very rare)
Pet's name: Rose
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
theirs:Joker dog (rare) and PPS october dog from 08 (rare)

the tribal is my fav pet.. but i dont know what to do

The first I'd say is unfair.

The second seems like it might be fair. People will give a lot for a joker and they're offering a Joker and another dog. Though that October 08 isn't the best offer ever. If the tribal is your favorite pet and you only have the one I wouldn't accept though, just because it is your favorite and it would be very hard to get another.

okay, thanks

[chaos.]

Also one more thing, im trying to get a sundog from july 08, and i guess i can trade my tribal, and i know the sundog is rarer, what else should i put in? and do you know anyone who has a sundog

[adakie]

okay, further complication --'''' now I don't know what to accept, the first person's offer or this new person's

their offer - december snowflake pps AND december flopeared white and pale blue dog with the little leafish thing on its hip

they asked for - cerberus, new advent rat, all three Halloween red dog adults, tri-tailed red and black target dog

anyone? help?