New Thread please lock <3

[Pideaux]

EDIT:

*Sorry, I am on my old cumputer, I can't edit my posts ^^;*


Is Joker + Rose PPS for Blue Sorbet

better, or is

Non ballon for Blue Sorbet

better?

I'm not sure about the Joker and Rose PPS but I can assure you the Nonballoon is not worth a sorbet. The Joker alone is worth more than a Nonballoon from the first trade. :3

@stonestable - To me it would look about right if they removed the rare rat from their side. But please get another opinion because I'm not entirely certain.

@Remnantium - I actually believe that would be a bit unfair to the Red Toxic (possibly even fair but I'm leaning towards unfair for them :3 ) - The other dog they are requesting shouldn't fill the gap between the Green and Red. It's not sought after at all really and isn't even listed on the rares list guide. :3 Please get one more opinion but I don't believe it to be unfair to you regardless.

[Misanthropic]

Alright thank you two =3 Any third opinions? What could I possibly add from this group: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... erid=91622

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=8225895&userid=91622&signature=TFRSJTijeUILE4OP8RNapQ

They sent this suggestion and I'm not sure which side I should add to or whether it is perhaps already fair o . o Any help? =3

[Catfight]

Thanks, Pideaux.

What would the nonballon dog need to add? How much of a difference is there?

[DaDwarf]

EDIT:

*Sorry, I am on my old cumputer, I can't edit my posts ^^;*


Is Joker + Rose PPS for Blue Sorbet

better, or is

Non ballon for Blue Sorbet

better?

Non balloon is not fair..Joker + rose PPS, i'm not sure.. I think it could be fair..maybe if another 08 dog would be added..

(Check out the rares list though viewtopic.php?f=20&t=112366&start=0)

[Panne]

Dark pawprint rat+Buckskin PPS+Pink Cookie+'08 Halloween cat
for
Joker?

If unfair to joker, what if i added a blue rose?

[Catfight]

Thanks,DaDwarf.

Nonballon + Galaxy bunny for Blue Sorbet?

[~ dawn ~]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=8236346&userid=152567&signature=eUEPHbZzh7RF63EKhfAALA
if not what should be added?

[Nikki Amaranti]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=8205115&userid=21619&signature=bqUEDQ56SQLv2ciK2z2snQ
^I need some urgent advice on this.

Those 3 for a Red-X, would it be fair?
What if those 3 were for a Red-X PPS? Would that be fair? (^_^)

I think it's unfair for both the Red-X and the X pps...

What should I ask them to add, to make it fair for the Red-X?

[Pideaux]

Thanks,DaDwarf.

Nonballon + Galaxy bunny for Blue Sorbet?

Still believe that is quite unfair to the sorbet - Galaxy Bunny can't be worth more than a mid ranged 08 advent, I believe. Although I'm not very experienced in bunnies. The others from around the same time with the exception of a couplethree are around that. :3

@Amy - Only assuming that the unknowns will go uncommon (although I'm starting to believe they will be common >.>) - It would be unfair to them slightly. I usually go the 4 uncommons per year of separation rule (of course it has it's exceptions). With the consideration of dogs vs other species, I'd still have to say a bit unfair to them personally. :3 Another thing to keep in mind is that the Malk Kois are now retired linearts although I'm uncertain how or if this even effects their rarity now >.>

[Mami]

Is this fair? If not, how much should I remove? :c

I'm not sure either, i think it's unfair to the rose dog.. Really, really unsure xD, ask someone else!

Alright, thank you anyway. <: Someone else's opinion?