The Trading Advice Thread (Previously FTT)

[Elwynie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=118005186&userid=1128065&signature=2z25olKkisIuly7r7Tiarw would 75 C$be fair for this? i thought not but,,, (we were discussing pricing so thats why my side is empty).

C$ Chart
this chart can help you calculate the value of the 40ish pets

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

someone help? i'm not sure about the value of these pets.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=118003105&userid=1010898&signature=ftL15Phz35wVyX-kAzLgxg

per the C$ Chart, a 2010 R is worth 25-35C$
so if you value your buns at 25 each then the trade would be fair

[Lesbainwolf]

is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=117999532&userid=866625&signature=Y_siukt72v0u0wAlBpNIBw am struggling with 24 store pets normal its one old rare

[Elwynie]

is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=117999532&userid=866625&signature=Y_siukt72v0u0wAlBpNIBw am struggling with 24 store pets normal its one old rare

an 09 VR non list is worth 3 old rares
a 2024 store pet is worth 1 old rare each ... they want 4 old rares for their 3 old rare pet ... unfair unless they add or you take away

[caster.]

I have a UR Apple and idk what is fair lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=117971637&userid=796216&signature=dOGk0sTAdD1wpO_Eb8I7CQ

Hello! I'll try my best here to assist ^^

Their side:
2010 R: 25-35C$ x6 | 150-210 c$
2010 VR: 50-70C$ x6 | 300-420 c$
2011 R: 25-35C$ x17 | 425-595 c$
2010 Christmas Black Hooves, antlers, jingle collar, winter saddle & grape soda: Found that they were a 2010 UC in 2022 so Im gonna gently bump this to VUCs.
VUC: 1-5C$ x5 | 5-25 c$
2011 Leprechaun hat & cupcakes: Found nothing noteworthy here, going to value at a VUC as well: 1-5c$ x2 | 2-10 c$

Your side:
UR Apple, tier 3 line 4: 600-800C$

Their total: 882-1260 c$
Your total: 600-800C$

I'd like to note that while they're technically offering more, most of those pets are low-demand (rabbits, rats, horses, bunnies, bwolves, etc). I personally wouldn't take this since you could get a lot better with the UR apple in my opinion. If those are mostly wishlist pets though, then go for it ^^

Yah they tried to offer mostly rats before and I didn't like it trades/viewtrade.php?id=117971460&userid=796216&signature=SoCsuxRg52pa2c6QNwdjzg
and they said the Apple has low demand too so they're offering low demand pets.

[Elwynie]

I have a UR Apple and idk what is fair lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=117971637&userid=796216&signature=dOGk0sTAdD1wpO_Eb8I7CQ

Hello! I'll try my best here to assist ^^

Their side:
2010 R: 25-35C$ x6 | 150-210 c$
2010 VR: 50-70C$ x6 | 300-420 c$
2011 R: 25-35C$ x17 | 425-595 c$
2010 Christmas Black Hooves, antlers, jingle collar, winter saddle & grape soda: Found that they were a 2010 UC in 2022 so Im gonna gently bump this to VUCs.
VUC: 1-5C$ x5 | 5-25 c$
2011 Leprechaun hat & cupcakes: Found nothing noteworthy here, going to value at a VUC as well: 1-5c$ x2 | 2-10 c$

Your side:
UR Apple, tier 3 line 4: 600-800C$

Their total: 882-1260 c$
Your total: 600-800C$

I'd like to note that while they're technically offering more, most of those pets are low-demand (rabbits, rats, horses, bunnies, bwolves, etc). I personally wouldn't take this since you could get a lot better with the UR apple in my opinion. If those are mostly wishlist pets though, then go for it ^^

Yah they tried to offer mostly rats before and I didn't like it trades/viewtrade.php?id=117971460&userid=796216&signature=SoCsuxRg52pa2c6QNwdjzg
and they said the Apple has low demand too so they're offering low demand pets.

all fruits (not food) have low demand(: so this would be up to you if youd like to trade your low apple for low pets or not
imo, the apple could still be traded easier than rats n other low pet fodder

[Lepid]

Just gonna address this one & get back to other ones later ^^

Yah they tried to offer mostly rats before and I didn't like it trades/viewtrade.php?id=117971460&userid=796216&signature=SoCsuxRg52pa2c6QNwdjzg
and they said the Apple has low demand too so they're offering low demand pets.

I decided to look into this and found that on the VR, ER & OMGSR Successful Trades Thread, the apple still does have a notable amount of demand. Here are a few examples (the 3 most recent from 2025 I believe) indicating that you can still get better pets than what they're offering. You can poke around that thread too to find more examples.

Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3

It may have lower demand but that doesn't prevent you from still being able to get pets that are worth 3-4 MA/600-800 c$ since it's a UR at the end of the day and is scarcer to get than most other pets.

(Basically agreeing with Elwynie on this one w/provided data.

[ithiria]

hi, we need some help with this item, please ♥
trades/viewtrade.php?id=118006257&userid=792998&signature=-ZhkfDTawsAqnAIQN494UQ
its from birthday 2009 and we both dont know whats its worth or if it has special demand,
thank you for helping

[Jokikaktus]

Would this be fair for both sides?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=118006317&userid=752492&signature=IL9oCYYFMKz2rvG-5fx-pg

[Elwynie]

Would this be fair for both sides?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=118006317&userid=752492&signature=IL9oCYYFMKz2rvG-5fx-pg

this would be unfair to their side(:
a 2024 store pet is only worth 1 old rare each
your side: 4 old rares
their side: 5 old rares + 2 EUC

[RoomOfTheForgotten]

Need help with this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=118002757&userid=845474&signature=pEla3ktRCuyfOpbVj4RRZg