The Trading Advice Thread (Previously FTT)

[Pastel-Axle]

Is this fair? Note I already have the cat, so it would be for trade fodder.

[uta1911]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115748952&userid=1088985&signature=y5mbEfJ_GqeGsU_YviYD-w

terrible with warrior cat worth if anyone can help

[DogSnob]

-
-
-
Can I get a second or third set of eyes on this trade please.
Thank you in advance. I get nervous with high value trades.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115751214&userid=39125&signature=7vCFCd6EqW_jydMzbXEHdQ

[sketchymurr]

Is this fair? Note I already have the cat, so it would be for trade fodder.

Using Horror's pricing, they're offering about 10-15 C$ and taking 13-20 C$ in exchange (lion: 3-4 C$, both snail/rat: 5-8 C$). I'd say do it only if you needed/wanted the cat, as it doesn't otherwise benefit you. (And since it's going to be fodder... maybe not.)

It's not a bad trade and mostly subjective at these price points.

[GoddessPersephone]

Requesting advice please. Would any of these be fair?

1

2


3


4

Any help would be appreciated

[Nekioka]

Hi, is this fair trade? I don't usually trade high value pets so I have no idea ^^'

[Lluca]

How are these? Is these fair or no? If not, how to make them fair? Thanks!

Trade 1

Trade 2

[Cina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115752888&userid=997296&signature=RqX5AnUwzQWLlTgnD2vCBA
Can i get an opinion on this? Im unsure on what my lion usually goes for, as I dont keep up with them often, nor do i know what their blue dog on their side goes for. Help is appreciated!

[Umbreon used Yawn]

Can someone help me？I'm not sure how to judge the transaction between items and pets
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734584

[Audrey_Bee]

Can someone help me？I'm not sure how to judge the transaction between items and pets
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734584

Hi! This is the wrong link. To ensure other people can see it, please copy the link at the bottom of the page when viewing the trade ❤️

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115752888&userid=997296&signature=RqX5AnUwzQWLlTgnD2vCBA
Can i get an opinion on this? Im unsure on what my lion usually goes for, as I dont keep up with them often, nor do i know what their blue dog on their side goes for. Help is appreciated!

Your amber pps lion is worth 5 old rares (or 0.5MA)
Their side going by rarity would be just under 5 old rares. The blue dog doesn't have special demand but I believe is a pet from the slumber party event ? Which generally can get slight overpay so with the dogs demand, maybe can equal to an old rare.
However, 2 old rares value, almost half of the entire value is a horse which are fairly low demand.
Your pps lion is very high demand.
I personally would want them to swap out the horse for a higher demand, or to add a small bit more value to make up for the difference, demand wise.
Unless you're looking for the horse for your collection ofc!

How are these? Is these fair or no? If not, how to make them fair? Thanks!

Trade 1

Trade 2

We can't see these trades, please make sure you copy the link from the bottom of the page when viewing your trade ❤️

Hi, is this fair trade? I don't usually trade high value pets so I have no idea ^^'

Hi!

Their Light leopard is true date so trades for around 3MA following the successful trades thread.
Your warriors are 0.5ma each so they add up to 2MA

The 3 old rares are 0.3MA , making your side total to 2.3MA for their 3MA.
So they are overpaying, however I would think it's a pretty fair trade demand wise as warriors have very high demand, however the leopard dogs have a mid demand. I personally think it's fair ❤️
Sorry some odd reason, TD warriors don't tend to be valued differently to RR so keep that in mind, if you value your TD warriors higher than 0.5MA !

Requesting advice please. Would any of these be fair?

1

2


3


4

Any help would be appreciated

The first one is fair (zonkey 2.5N = Tree 1.5N aussie 1N)
However, the tree does have poor demand and surprisingly the aussie dog doesn't have the greatest demand either, I have personally experienced a struggle with both of them in the past so I would personally not take the trade / ask for overpay to fill the demand gap!

The second one is incredibly unfair to you. Either they're unsure of values or are trying to take advantage of you not knowing rarities as well as others. But I like to assume good intentions. Their dog is 1MA (0.1 N) and your smores are 1.5-2N. The 100 C$ doesn't add enough value to think about really.

The third one i would need to work out. But definitely keep in mind all but one of their pets have very low demand.
*edit* their side is worth 5.5-6.5 nons. The scale is due to the mint tess horse being valued at 0.5-1 nons *however* they all have that scale, bu are all traded away for 0.5 nons...so i would personally value them at 0.5 nons when dealing with higher demand pets on the other side of the trade, especially.
Your side is 5-6 nons. The dogtag usually fetches closer to 1.5 nons unless being traded up for lower demand it seems. Same with the smores, it goes between the scale. So if we value them both at the 1.75 non, it'll make your side 5.5 nons which would add up to their lowest demand. So it is a fair trade, however you do just need to keep in mind the demand. It's a lot of pets they're offering, but its harder to trade them. If you have the patience to trade, take it. If you want easier trading, keep your pets ❤️ you're probably more likely to get the 2 non value of your dogtag and smores than getting the full 1 non value of the mint tess horses. Or if they're able to add 0.5 non to their side for the demand gap that could be a better trade.
It's always tricky giving advice for demand as everyone has their own opinions on the pets. But this is what I would do if I had that trade myself <3

The fourth one is tricky, they're valuing both their pet and your pet at their highest scale, the flamingo being 2-2.5N and your smores at 1.5-2N. The added pets equal to 0.5 N
So if you value the flamingo at 2.5 nons, it would be fair.
However, compared to the smores, the flamingo generally gets the lower end, usually a solid 2 nons looking at the successful trades thread, whereas the smores usually get around 1.75 nons ish. This is purely down to the demand of the flamingo being lower. If you want the flamingo, I would just take away one of the dogs and maybe the warrior on your side too. However if you're wanting to trade around with your list pets, I would keep your side just due to ease of trading and demand !