The Trading Advice Thread (Previously FTT)

[Kuj0]

I need some help determining the value of these offers from my auction! Valuing the Sakura at 2MA, thank you!
1
2
3

- snip -

for bid 2 -

your side = 2ma

their side =
(tier 6, line 5) baby g-money = .5ma
triclops = ~70 c$
pink creamsicle = 100 c$
green august = 100 c$
blue kimono koi = 100 c$
all rares + 50 c$ together = ~.5ma
2024 store = 1 old rare

their total = a little over 1.5ma

so value wise this is (technically) fair, but using your values, this is an underpay! the malks on their side are pretty decent, but i haven't seen any specific overpays with them. they are pretty popular though, due to being malks!

- snip -

Hi! I sent through bid 2 so forgive me if there is a bit of bias here. However, I believe my bid is around 2 MA, no? Using Horror's list:

The PPS horse is true date so would be around 0.75 MA rather than 0.5 MA.
The two '09 VRs would be about 0.25 MA each (or 2.5 old rares), so 0.5 MA total.
The '10/'11 rares would be 0.5 MA total.
The VR koi would be 0.2 MA/2 old rares.
Then the store would be 0.1 MA/1 old rare.

So total would be around 2 MA, if I'm not mistaken, not taking into account the C$. Again, I am the one that sent the bid so apologies if there is any sort of bias but I am quite confident in my maths 😅

[shurikenfox]

Would anyone be able to help with this bulk trade? I’m not great at calculating newer, more common pets for older, less common pets. Thank you in advance.

[uta1911]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734615&userid=1088985&signature=BNsP3l9zJpN4U4SEulFjWQ

trading up! again not good with store pets sorry and thank you in advance

[kayn]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734615&userid=1088985&signature=BNsP3l9zJpN4U4SEulFjWQ

trading up! again not good with store pets sorry and thank you in advance

hello! i’m using values from horror’s guide for this

their side:
ur cat = 3 nons

your side:
2012 store pets = 1 ma each (3 in the trade, so 3 ma total)
phoenix dogs = 1 ma each (4 in the trade, so 4 ma total)
corgi = 1.5 ma
adult dragoncats = .5 ma each (3 in the trade, so 1.5 ma total)
adult manticores = .5 ma each (4 in the trade, so 2 ma total)
pps manticore = 1 ma
carnival lions = 4 old rares each (4 in the trade, so 16 old rares/1.6 ma total)
ur tree = 1.5 non
total: around 2.9 non, not too far off from the value of the cat

[kayn]

how is this?

hello! i’m using the values on horror’s guide for this.

your side:
ur peas = .5 non / 5 ma

their side:
jayfeather warrior = .5 ma
bongo bwolf = .5-.75 ma
gray spotted bun = 1 ma
light gray husky = 1 ma
pale spotted advent = 1 ma
fae fox = inconsistent, could be anywhere from 1 old rare to .5 ma
drafts = 3 old rares each, so .6 ma
total: 4.75-5.25 ma, so depending on how you value the fae fox it could either be slightly under or even. the peas do have poor demand though and a few pets on their side (like the fae fox & their warrior) have good demand

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734615&userid=1088985&signature=BNsP3l9zJpN4U4SEulFjWQ

trading up! again not good with store pets sorry and thank you in advance

hello! i’m using values from horror’s guide for this

their side:
ur cat = 3 nons

your side:
2012 store pets = 1 ma each (3 in the trade, so 3 ma total)
phoenix dogs = 1 ma each (4 in the trade, so 4 ma total)
corgi = 1.5 ma
adult dragoncats = .5 ma each (3 in the trade, so 1.5 ma total)
adult manticores = .5 ma each (4 in the trade, so 2 ma total)
pps manticore = 1 ma
carnival lions = 4 old rares each (4 in the trade, so 16 old rares/1.6 ma total)
ur tree = 1.5 non
total: around 2.9 non, not too far off from the value of the cat

Seconding this, I was calculating their side myself!
Your side is as follows:
Fairy Goat = 1MA
Wonderland BWolves (Bandersnatch and Jabberwocky) = 2MA (1 each)
2013 Phoenix dogs = 4MA (1 each)
2013 Corgi = 1.5-2 MA (note that I’ve seen it go for both in successful trades, but from what I know 1.5 is more common)
Adult Dragon Cats = 1.5 MA (0.5 each)
Adult Manticores = 2MA (0.5 each)
PPS manticore = 1 MA
2017 Carnival lions = 16 old rares/1.6MA (4 old rares each)
UR Orange Tree = 1.5 nons/15 MA
TOTAL = 29.6-30.1MA = 2.96-3.01 nons
The cat’s listed value is 3 nons, so this isn’t a bad trade at all! It’s up to your preference, as to whether you’d prefer to trade up or retain your quantity store pets that are a hugely useful trading resource.

[uta1911]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115734615&userid=1088985&signature=BNsP3l9zJpN4U4SEulFjWQ

trading up! again not good with store pets sorry and thank you in advance

hello! i’m using values from horror’s guide for this

their side:
ur cat = 3 nons

your side:
2012 store pets = 1 ma each (3 in the trade, so 3 ma total)
phoenix dogs = 1 ma each (4 in the trade, so 4 ma total)
corgi = 1.5 ma
adult dragoncats = .5 ma each (3 in the trade, so 1.5 ma total)
adult manticores = .5 ma each (4 in the trade, so 2 ma total)
pps manticore = 1 ma
carnival lions = 4 old rares each (4 in the trade, so 16 old rares/1.6 ma total)
ur tree = 1.5 non
total: around 2.9 non, not too far off from the value of the cat

thank you so much!

another question:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=115748952&userid=1088985&signature=y5mbEfJ_GqeGsU_YviYD-w

terrible with warrior cat worth if anyone can help

[scythean]

thoughts? i'm not really sure the worths of nick pets ^^

[GoddessPersephone]

Requesting advice please. Would any of these be fair?

1

2


3


4

[Spine]

im weird about lower rarities; is this fair?