The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nyx119]

Is this fair?

I’m able to edit it and send it back

Also need help on this one. I struggle with item trades

[crrow]

Is this fair?

I’m able to edit it and send it back

Also need help on this one. I struggle with item trades

I know in the first trade that it would be unfair to them! Yours pets don’t add up to the old rare on their side, but are worth more than just the more recent pets.

Your plushie is from 2024 Halloween event, and theirs is from the 2023 camping event. This would also technically be unfair to them!

[Coco]

♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115671787&userid=658989&signature=8y-5DzVQaFx0FaaYZPq_5g
♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115667968&userid=658989&signature=mg9mXGU_UG9wU9qjKeKBKw
♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115668270&userid=658989&signature=LZK7u6Py9HuQFlnT2mMS8Q

are these fair for my raven? not really sure how much the raven is worth - it's been years since i've played this game. thank you in advance!

[joe cool]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115671787&userid=658989&signature=8y-5DzVQaFx0FaaYZPq_5g

is this fair? thank you in advance! ♥

Massively unfair to you. The raven is 7 nons and the red cerberus is 7 nons as well. Anything else on your side is going over the value.

Values yoinked from here. Hope this helped!

[Coco]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115671787&userid=658989&signature=8y-5DzVQaFx0FaaYZPq_5g

is this fair? thank you in advance! ♥

Massively unfair to you. The raven is 7 nons and the red cerberus is 7 nons as well. Anything else on your side is going over the value.

Values yoinked from here. Hope this helped!

thank you! how much is that masked little guy worth? i've been getting many trades for him after opening up my groups

[crrow]

♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115671787&userid=658989&signature=8y-5DzVQaFx0FaaYZPq_5g
♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115667968&userid=658989&signature=mg9mXGU_UG9wU9qjKeKBKw
♥ trades/viewtrade.php?id=115668270&userid=658989&signature=LZK7u6Py9HuQFlnT2mMS8Q

are these fair for my raven? not really sure how much the raven is worth - it's been years since i've played this game. thank you in advance!

For the first trade, they are asking for overpay. The red cerb is technically equal value to the raven dog, and I think they have equal demand. I would not accept this ;u;

Second trade, Im not very good with c$ value, so I’d ask for someone else to help with that! From what I can tell they have roughly 6.4/6.5 non in pets/items with okay-ish/moderate demand. I’m sure they are overpaying in c$ to make up for the missed demand, and often times it is really hard to trade off c$ of rather pets.

Third trade would be overpay in their side. Both Salem cats are 3 nons, and the pps dragon is 2.5 non bringing their side to 8.5 nons. All of their pets have pretty stable demand as well, so it seems like a good offer to me!

Also, the “masked” pets or kitsunes are worth 3-4 MA, but recently have been getting 0.5 nons worth in trades! For reference, 1 MA = 10 2010-2012 rares, and 1 non = 100 2010-2012 rares.

[joe cool]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115671787&userid=658989&signature=8y-5DzVQaFx0FaaYZPq_5g

is this fair? thank you in advance! ♥

Massively unfair to you. The raven is 7 nons and the red cerberus is 7 nons as well. Anything else on your side is going over the value.

Values yoinked from here. Hope this helped!

thank you! how much is that masked little guy worth? i've been getting many trades for him after opening up my groups

If you're referring to either one of these guys (Jade / Black Kitsunes), they're around 3-4 MA each. They're from the same store litter from 2013 if you want to take a peek in the archive. If you were referring to other pets, let me know and I'll help out to the best of my ability!

Values yoinked from here again :3

[FairSky]

Hi there! ♡

It's been over a decade since I've last been on this site properly. A lot has changed and I no longer have a good sense for how values work. 😅

Could I therefore maybe get some opinions on this trade? The other person seems lovely, I just don't really have the ability to evaluate things properly.

Trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115638032&userid=28639&signature=OiX3NGdBVBCbJX__kK3oQQ

Thank you in advance! ♡

your side:
orange cerb = 10 NONs
(ranges from 8-10, but are rarely traded)

your total: 10 NONs (or 100 MA)

their side:
(line 7, tier 1) UR phoenix = 1.5 NON
(line 7, tier 1) UR holly dog = 1.5 NON
(line 7, tier 1) UR galaxy cat = 1.5 NON
(line 12, tier 1) UR grapes = .5 NON
(line 4, tier 3) red x pps = 4 MA
(line 2, tier 5) BMD = .75 NON
(line 2, tier 3) pink sorbet = .75 NON
blue android = .5 NON
6000 c$ = 3 NON

their total value: 10.4 NONs (or 104 MA)

so, this is fair (technically a small overpay but yk.. orange cerb is really difficult to get!) to you! i cannot give you insight on demand or any recommendations as ive never traded using any of these pets before, but i do know that it is very hard to get both the orange and red cerb! i will also warn that it is difficult to trade up for good pets using c$. but this trade is up to you!

please get a second opinion though, as i got most of the stuff from horrors guide! i just know that its fair, i wouldn't know demand of any of their side <3

Thank you so much, I really appreciate, the explanation and breakdown! ♡

[FairSky]

Hi there! ♡

It's been over a decade since I've last been on this site properly. A lot has changed and I no longer have a good sense for how values work. 😅

Could I therefore maybe get some opinions on this trade? The other person seems lovely, I just don't really have the ability to evaluate things properly.

Trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=115638032&userid=28639&signature=OiX3NGdBVBCbJX__kK3oQQ

Thank you in advance! ♡

Allot of their pets are low demand, If you want to trade down I suggest getting pets that will be easier to trade off in the long run, unless you're specifically looking for those pets. As for the c$, it's hard to buy List pets for c$ because not many people sell them, so I would ask for pets to fill in that space instead.

Orange Cerb has been trading for 12N consistently from the Successful Trade Thread, not 10N

Thank you so much for your response! That's all super useful information, and very much appreciated! ♡

[itherin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=115617822&userid=834516&signature=xyU5HxZuxoIuYSyRmELeLw

Is this a fair trade?

Still need help on this!