The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DaydreamNarrator]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114066480&userid=640608&signature=0h4qh8xuaTFszMnUQ5ek-g

Suuuper unsure about this one; pretty sure the sun jewel is higher list-wise, but what about demand?

[texastoast]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114066480&userid=640608&signature=0h4qh8xuaTFszMnUQ5ek-g

Suuuper unsure about this one; pretty sure the sun jewel is higher list-wise, but what about demand?

Sunjewel is lower demand and is only 3-3.5N. Sunjewel side needs to add as the dragon goes for 4.5N consistently.

[mercer]

I don't know item worth, could I get some help?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114050013&userid=992984&signature=IEuOSZu2WjS0EXIvbiEF0w

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114052193&userid=992984&signature=gZGeUou9n35WMlxiQmJUBA got automatically cancelled :(

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114067171&userid=992984&signature=YanxHYsg2eLsh08DMmSINw

Also aaaa help- I got a trade with really high values involved,,, is this worth it? Is the demand good compared to my side? I struggle to trade off anything with less demand ;w;

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114059750&userid=992984&signature=6SJpZfo7ZTEAKsM1xV8ssA automatically cancelled now too ;;

[Raya36]

Would love an opinion on this one. I was originally offering 1200 C$ for the Cheshire cat. Not sure if the added pets keeps it fair still?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114062964&userid=769200&signature=9tMUssvzMMioNwaqAhSJ5w

[Woofzard]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114064287&userid=601475&signature=LOwvVd81IE-Y8IsgVm2jYQ
I'm bad with counting , how much do the vrs add up to ?

[texastoast]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114064287&userid=601475&signature=LOwvVd81IE-Y8IsgVm2jYQ
I'm bad with counting , how much do the vrs add up to ?

unfair to the bottom, the pets on the top add up to 20 old rares and the pets on the bottom add up to 25 old rares. The pets on the top c$ wise is up to 620 c$ while the pets on the bottom are 825 c$. I would add in either 5 old rares or c$ to make up the difference, but I would also consider keeping your side for something better as none of their pets have any real demand except the sitting cat.

[Jaybat]

anyone have thoughts on this one? the items are older, and I'm not great with values already.

[Snippet-1213]

is this trade fair? i’ve been valuing the Zodiac dogs at 0.5 MA and have had several successful trades treating them as that. The other party for this trade says they’d be willing to trade just one of the Zodiacs because “the zodiac dogs have been going for 1 MA for a while now” but that’s honestly not what i’ve been seeing or experiencing. should i take the trade or wait for a better one? is what they said abt the zodiacs true? thanks!

[puffy]

is this trade fair? i’ve been valuing the Zodiac dogs at 0.5 MA and have had several successful trades treating them as that. The other party for this trade says they’d be willing to trade just one of the Zodiacs because “the zodiac dogs have been going for 1 MA for a while now” but that’s honestly not what i’ve been seeing or experiencing. should i take the trade or wait for a better one? is what they said abt the zodiacs true? thanks!

zodiacs are 0.5 ma, regardless of rr or td. the only thing is, it’s easier to get 1 ma/close to 1 ma only c$ wise- there was a time where 300 c$ for zodiacs was more common. now, people can still sell them at that, but it’s not as common, and i’m seeing more people price around the 200-250 range. but pet-wise, i’ve mostly seen them go for .5 ma. i guess they can be a “get up to 1 ma” depending on the person, but it’s not solid 1 ma. a lot of people will still name their pets that, though.

here are some successful zodiac dog trades. even true dates, the majority of them are valued at 0.5 ma :]

[shurikenfox]

is this trade fair? i’ve been valuing the Zodiac dogs at 0.5 MA and have had several successful trades treating them as that. The other party for this trade says they’d be willing to trade just one of the Zodiacs because “the zodiac dogs have been going for 1 MA for a while now” but that’s honestly not what i’ve been seeing or experiencing. should i take the trade or wait for a better one? is what they said abt the zodiacs true? thanks!

From what I’ve heard and seen on occasion, TD Zodiacs can get up to 1MA. Both your Zodiacs in this Trade Suggestion I believe are TD, thus why they may be saying as such. But honestly, even TD Zodiacs I’ve seen more often than not get traded for 0.5MA as well.

If you want my take on it, either instance is fair, since the value of a TD Zodiac is considered ranging from 0.5MA to 1MA. It’s up to you and them to make the final call, though.