The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[reefspeef]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114046698&userid=837967&signature=ghYkOpZNH1v1_OPQsEQDlA
are they overpaying? thx!

[jprspereira]

hi! would someone mind looking at this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114051994&userid=408365&signature=cfuPQUqP3IRkhjjuKtmtgQ

I’ve been trying to go by Horror's Rarity Math, and according Oreoz's script calculator, my side is worth 91-122 C$ and what I added on theirs is worth 77-107 C$. i'm really struggling to figure out if this is fair because that calculator doesn't factor in demand/species.
TLDR:
- demand wise some of my pets are less desirable species
- my pets are significantly older
- their pets are mostly store pets

They're overpaying. Your pets might be older by the date, but store pets are immediately worth a rare 2010/2011 once they're out of the store So see this trade as them having 3 2010 rares on their side (with higher demand).

One good piece of information is that Oreoz's calculates "old rares" as 30C$. So if a store pet is worth 2 old rares, the script defaults to 60C$ which is not a good way of measure. The C$ values are mostly for trades with no store pets/list pets (0.5MA+). In other words, with pets that are 2012 and younger.

[mercer]

I don't know item worth, could I get some help?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114050013&userid=992984&signature=IEuOSZu2WjS0EXIvbiEF0w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114052193&userid=992984&signature=gZGeUou9n35WMlxiQmJUBA

[Pyca]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114052678&userid=933497&signature=UHkRLKb2ov3zb-_h1AVLHg

tempting, but would love some help if anyones willing!

[jprspereira]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114052678&userid=933497&signature=UHkRLKb2ov3zb-_h1AVLHg

tempting, but would love some help if anyones willing!

Their side:
Winged Blood Dog - 2MA

Your side:
Queen of Hearts - 1MA
Realistic Breed Dog - 1MA
Tiger - 0.5MA
Feather Dragon - 0.4MA

You'd be overpaying by 0.9MA

[The Orphaner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035710&userid=207994&signature=a8yaVpO5UnhTeQ14bDODtQ

Can someone help me figure out this lil zebra rare? Before my hiatus, I had people offering BULK '09 rares for it

What's so special about it?? I've held onto it bc its super cute

AND

As background I am partially retiring and keeping only pets I like, I'm 100% okay trading bulk pets or rares for bulk items but I dont know very well the worth of items or how to calculate...

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114038161&userid=207994&signature=32ntZqUUEutqDfoFDOVq7A

[Kecko]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114046698&userid=837967&signature=ghYkOpZNH1v1_OPQsEQDlA
are they overpaying? thx!

Can't see the trade. Use the link at the bottom of the trade

[American Honey]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041507&userid=1055788&signature=wl-DuvRD3ZRnNe2LPv0nOw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041480&userid=1055788&signature=mbXyUV22hHDyG7ot56f_5g

I'm not sure about these two. Any help is appreciated!

[jaxonlynx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114046698&userid=837967&signature=ghYkOpZNH1v1_OPQsEQDlA
are they overpaying? thx!

• sort of! just remove one of the rares and i think it's fair! ^_^

[beignet]

thoughts on their side's demand? i would think im essentially trading for the balloon dog mainly so im wondering how the current demand stacks up against the store pets? wondering about this one too.