The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mushroomish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041226&userid=978329&signature=SxR5JXjaDLHGRGYhGaTNKg

Would love some help on this, thank you!

[jprspereira]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041226&userid=978329&signature=SxR5JXjaDLHGRGYhGaTNKg

Would love some help on this, thank you!

Their side: 2MA (=20 rares 2010/2011)
Your side: 1MA + 1.5MA (TD) = 2.5MA (=25 rares 2010/2011)

Unfair to you (:

[mushroomish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041226&userid=978329&signature=SxR5JXjaDLHGRGYhGaTNKg

Would love some help on this, thank you!

Their side: 2MA (=20 rares 2010/2011)
Your side: 1MA + 1.5MA (TD) = 2.5MA (=25 rares 2010/2011)

Unfair to you (:

Thank you for your help!

[debijayn]

I'd love someone's opinion on this trade, my brain is mathed out; I don't care about the items so much so however you value them is fine:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041179&userid=306914&signature=6ddlmvP4UD_YdESJ1TUmIg

[mercer]

Does this look even?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114038006&userid=992984&signature=CNmsuYTYfFbBzWUNEk0U9w

[American Honey]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041480&userid=1055788&signature=mbXyUV22hHDyG7ot56f_5g

Im not sure about this. Any help is appreciated

[jaxonlynx]

I'd love someone's opinion on this trade, my brain is mathed out; I don't care about the items so much so however you value them is fine:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041179&userid=306914&signature=6ddlmvP4UD_YdESJ1TUmIg

• you would have to wait for someone who is more versed in item values because, i have no clue about them. what i do know is pet values! ^_^
• the 2010 extremely uncommon is worth 8-10C$ while the pets they want is worth 13-24C$.
• pretty much, it's overpay on what they want compared to what they're offering. not to mention the value of the items might increase the value your side has.
• in my opinion, the 2022 rare for the 2010 extremely uncommon are in similiar value to each other (8-10C$ = 7-10C$) so, if you remove the rest of the pets and leave just the rare, i think it would be fair in my opinion.

[beignet]

thoughts demand-wise?

[nubbyqueen]

I have 2 I need help with

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032257&userid=475417&signature=cfnxncRuVdTevhNTrQvkLQ
and
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114037400&userid=475417&signature=sMZhT35me-avFvtD6u5nVA

[SonrienteMuerte]

Asking about a few trades, as I'm confused on the demand (and names) on some of these. Thank you

Trade 1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114041035&userid=15385&signature=kT9H1rf8sEFyUZ7WYC3d0g

Trade 2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035852&userid=15385&signature=IcnR8XzFucLwdYOgHUSyrw