The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kabuski]

Opinions on these?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035134&userid=795870&signature=EKl197bw2woZASwXOSlQaA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032591&userid=795870&signature=fzpj9lHnlHrwThOSZlOksw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114034668&userid=795870&signature=WD4CKhOySD6LtFevwbtc8w

[puffy]

Opinions on these?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035134&userid=795870&signature=EKl197bw2woZASwXOSlQaA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032591&userid=795870&signature=fzpj9lHnlHrwThOSZlOksw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114034668&userid=795870&signature=WD4CKhOySD6LtFevwbtc8w

1. ur zonkey is 2n. yellow sorb is 0.5n and ur tree is 1.5n. the tree's demand was really bad a few months ago- it's gone up a little since then from what i've seen, but it still struggles depending on the person. yellow sorb and ur zonkey demand is good.

2. BEG is 1.5n solid. true date grinner is 3 ma, basilisk is 3-4 ma (but it's pretty easy to get 4, or atleast 3.5 ma for it), nonjewel is 1n, feather dragon is 4 old rares, and store dog is 2 old rares. that's 1.66-1.76n. your side is over.

3. true date jokers are 2.5n. ur bee is 3n. they're over by 0.5n

[mercer]

I sent a trade, and wondered after the fact if I might be overpaying? Or under? (Totally fine with someone just eyeballing it, just need opinions!)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114037274&userid=992984&signature=5eOWQANABVLkb9C2yaCMug

[nubbyqueen]

I got offered this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032257&userid=475417&signature=cfnxncRuVdTevhNTrQvkLQ

Is this fair?

[The Orphaner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035710&userid=207994&signature=a8yaVpO5UnhTeQ14bDODtQ

Can someone help me figure out this lil zebra rare? Before my hiatus, I had people offering BULK '09 rares for it

What's so special about it?? I've held onto it bc its super cute

AND

As background I am partially retiring and keeping only pets I like, I'm 100% okay trading bulk pets or rares for bulk items but I dont know very well the worth of items or how to calculate...

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114038161&userid=207994&signature=32ntZqUUEutqDfoFDOVq7A

[Glizzyboi17]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114037433&userid=1092304&signature=YhWmVGdiofrEWouWAeO-eA


How is this

[jaxonlynx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114035710&userid=207994&signature=a8yaVpO5UnhTeQ14bDODtQ

Can someone help me figure out this lil zebra rare? Before my hiatus, I had people offering BULK '09 rares for it

What's so special about it?? I've held onto it bc its super cute

AND

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114037464&userid=207994&signature=za1_QMihChoVS8wqw9znDQ

These rares for some old staff pets?? I dont quite know the value of staffs asides the olders are pricey

• (this is just for the second trade)
• the two rares are worth 5C$ each and the 2021 very uncommon can range from 1-5C$
• on the other side, the very uncommon staff is also worth 1-5C$ and the uncommon staff is worth 1-3C$
• i'd say remove one of the rares from the offer because, while staffs are popular, i don't think they are worth two rares and a very uncommon.
• specifically the staffs that i personally think are worth overpay is the oldest which is from 2013 but, that's just me.
• needless to say, the staffs aren't impossible to get without having to trade a new rare away for it so, just remove one of the rares and the values would be more leveled.
• i do not take species into consideration because i don't personally think that's a valid way of determining trades especially different species trades.
• yes dogs/wolves are some of the most popular species and staff pets are popular no matter their year, i still consider them a normal monthly pet with some demand.

[Sali]

Can I get some help with this trade? c:

Trade

[beignet]

thoughts demand-wise?

[minoosh]

hi hi its been a while so im not up to date with rarites/demand.
would this be fair?